Most forecasts for a housing recovery start with mortgage rates. When borrowing costs ease, the thinking goes, buyers come back. But in metros built around one dominant industry, the deciding variable may be whether buyers trust their paychecks.
That is the case in Seattle, according to Kenny Pleasant, owner of NextHome Prolific, a Seattle-area brokerage focused on residential sales and land acquisition for builders. Asked what would need to change for the market to regain momentum, Pleasant put buyer confidence in tech employment first, home prices second, and interest rates third.
“The dust needs to settle,” he says. Buyers, in his view, need to reach the point where they can say, “I feel stable in my position.”
For years, that stability was a given. Amazon, Microsoft, Starbucks, Costco, and Boeing have long anchored the regional economy, and tech salaries pushed prices to the point where, Pleasant says, “a million dollars gets you a teardown lot.” Since late last year, AI-driven restructuring and layoffs have shaken the buyer pool those salaries supported.
That has changed the shape of the slowdown. Pleasant estimates pending sales are down close to 30% year over year, while sellers are still getting about 97% of their list price.
Market data suggests Seattle’s pullback is among the sharpest in the country, with pending sales falling roughly twice as fast as the national rate. Prices have moved far less. A market where sales drop this much faster than prices is waiting on something other than a better deal, and in Seattle, Pleasant argues, that something is job security.
Layoffs Reach Upper Earners
Pleasant has seen the disruption up close. One of his clients had put down earnest money on a new construction home and was waiting to close when a layoff letter arrived from Microsoft. The contract had to be canceled.
He has heard similar accounts from other agents, including one involving a buyer in the middle of purchasing a luxury home who received the same kind of letter. To Pleasant, that signals the cuts are no longer limited to entry-level and mid-level roles. Senior, well-paid employees are feeling the shift as well. That matters in Seattle, where high-tech salaries have long supported demand at the top of the market. When those buyers pull back, the homes that depended on them feel it first, and Pleasant says the high end is now among the slowest segments he sees.
Uncertainty Freezes Employed Buyers
Layoffs remove some buyers from the market, but uncertainty removes many more. Those who have been laid off, Pleasant notes, at least know where they stand. The far larger group still employed does not, and that group is the buyer pool Seattle’s market depends on.
“Someone that’s stable and has not received a layoff has to go to work every day wondering when is the next round of layoffs,” he says. “They’re not looking to make any moves.”
That is the core of Pleasant’s argument. A buyer who fears losing their income is not weighing a monthly payment; they are weighing whether to take on a mortgage at all. Lower rates make the payment cheaper but do nothing to answer that question. Pleasant is not convinced the cuts are over, and until employees believe they are, he expects many of the region’s highest earners to stay on the sidelines.
Why Rates Rank Last
Pleasant does not dismiss borrowing costs. He describes the current buyer pool as stagnant because job uncertainty, high rates, and high prices are hitting at once. If buyers could again lock in rates near 3%, as they did in 2021 and 2022, he says their mindset might change.
But he doubts rates alone are what is keeping buyers away. Historically, he says, rates have not been what keeps buyers out of the market: “people are still going to buy houses.” Rate buydowns and other incentives are available today, and demand still has not returned.
That runs counter to a national conversation that treats Federal Reserve policy as the main lever for housing demand. A buyer can absorb a higher mortgage payment with a reliable paycheck. A buyer unsure whether their role will exist next year is unlikely to sign a contract at any rate.
Demand Shift Reaches Builders
With fewer buyers in the pipeline, the pressure has moved to the supply side, where construction costs have already strained project math. Pleasant, whose business has historically centered on sourcing land for builders, says many projects no longer work under any assumption.
Even if the builder got the land for free, he says, “they still would not be able to make the numbers work because the cost of building has gone up so much.”
Builders are responding in different ways. Some are closing shop. Some production builders are moving into house flipping to avoid holding land or finished homes they cannot sell. Those staying in new construction are buying now for projects that will be ready in two to three years. “Anything that needs to come on the market this year, next year, they feel like it’s not going to be a good investment for them,” Pleasant says.
Thin margins also leave little room for extras. Pleasant says green certification is usually a secondary conversation for buyers. One builder he works with set out to build net zero homes but, by his estimate, has completed only one or two out of hundreds, because buyer demand has not caught up with the added cost.
Permits Stretch Carrying Costs
Seattle’s permitting timelines add to the strain. Permits in the city have taken up to 18 months, and while Pleasant says that has softened somewhat, permitting remains the biggest obstacle he sees.
The problem is the interest clock. A builder starts paying interest the day they buy the land. Every month spent waiting on approval is a month of debt with no revenue, and in a slow market those months can erase whatever margin a project had left.
So builders are pushing that risk onto others. Most of those Pleasant works with will only buy land that already has an approved permit, which leaves property owners to absorb the wait. The result is fewer deals getting done and less new housing moving forward.
Zoning Gains Lag Costs
Washington’s middle housing rules, which allow more units on lots once limited to single-family homes, were expected to unlock new supply. Pleasant says they may in the long term, “but we’re not seeing any immediate changes.”
Part of the reason is that additional units do not add value in proportion to their number. The floor area ratio was changed alongside the middle housing rules, and on the Eastside, in cities such as Bellevue and Kirkland, Pleasant says that change can actually reduce a lot’s value to a developer.
In lower-priced areas of south King County, construction costs alone can rule a project out. There, Pleasant says, the cost of building new homes can exceed what those homes would sell for, so the extra units the rules allow never make financial sense. “You automatically are out of that deal,” he says. “It just doesn’t pencil from the beginning.” New zoning capacity counts for little where home values sit below the cost of construction.
The buyers still active in this segment are mostly local small builders and developers.
What Must Change First
Pleasant’s order of operations is clear: employment confidence first, prices second, rates third. He does not predict how long the first will take. “Who knows how long that’ll take,” he says.
For investors and builders watching Seattle, that ordering matters. A rate cut may ease monthly payments, but in a market where demand rests on one industry’s payroll, it is unlikely to bring buyers back on its own. The signal to watch, by Pleasant’s account, is whether tech employment stabilizes long enough for buyers to plan beyond the next round of layoffs.
About the Expert: Kenny Pleasant is the owner of NextHome Prolific, a Seattle-area residential brokerage he founded in 2021 after working at Keller Williams, Windermere, and RE/MAX. His work focuses on residential sales, land acquisition for builders, and new construction.
This article is based on information provided by the expert source cited above. It is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or real estate advice. Readers should conduct their own research and consult qualified professionals before making any real estate or financial decisions.