In parts of the Midwest where the housing market still favors sellers, a split is emerging that has less to do with location than with condition. Two houses can sit side by side in the same neighborhood, built around the same time, and sell at noticeably different prices. The difference, according to Jean Lewis, who leads a five-person team serving the O’Fallon and Edwardsville markets on the Illinois side of St. Louis, is whether the home needs work. Buyers squeezed by higher rates, rising insurance, and Illinois’s steep property taxes have no financial room left for renovation after closing.
Lewis says the conversations with buyers have shifted noticeably over the past year. Buyers are no longer focused on just the mortgage number. They are looking at the full monthly obligation – principal, interest, taxes, and insurance – and that fuller picture is changing what they are willing to buy.
With mortgage rates in the sevens, property taxes in Illinois running higher than most states, and insurance costs climbing, the monthly housing bill has grown well beyond the mortgage itself. In the O’Fallon market, where the average home price runs around $330,000 according to Lewis, those added costs eat into what a household can afford after move-in.
“People are more focused on not just what their mortgage is going to be, but what the full payment’s going to be,” Lewis says. That awareness has a direct effect on which homes attract offers and which sit. When the monthly obligation is already stretched, there is nothing left for a new roof, updated kitchen, or deferred repairs.
In a lower-rate environment, a buyer might absorb a home’s flaws and plan to fix them over time. At today’s costs, that math does not work for many households. Lewis says buyers at the price points she works in “don’t have that extra 20, 30, $40,000 to do renovations.” The result is a growing premium on homes that are ready to live in from day one.
This pattern is especially pronounced among military families stationed at nearby Scott Air Force Base, many of whom know they will be reassigned within a few years. They lack both the time and the budget to take on a project. But Lewis says the preference for move-in ready homes extends beyond military buyers. Across her market, buyers are choosing to pay more for a home in strong condition rather than save on purchase price and face repair bills they cannot fund.
Sellers who have let maintenance slide – not dramatic neglect, just the slow accumulation of deferred updates – are discovering that their homes sit longer and eventually require price reductions. Lewis notes that buyers “are willing to pay for a home that’s in better condition, even though it might be right next door to a home that’s fine, just hasn’t been updated.”
Lewis says the O’Fallon market still has limited inventory – roughly 2.3 to 2.5 months of supply, according to her tracking, up from about 1.6 months a year earlier. That is still a seller’s market by traditional standards. But the increase means buyers have just enough choice to be selective, and they are using that leverage to avoid homes that will cost them money after closing.
Well-priced, well-maintained homes still move within days, Lewis says. The homes generating price reductions are not in bad neighborhoods or undesirable locations. They simply need work that today’s buyers cannot afford to take on. Sellers who still expect their homes to sell within a week regardless of condition are, in Lewis’s words, “very disappointed and panicked” when that does not happen – and price reductions are following quickly.
The gap between move-in ready and everything else is financial, not cosmetic. Today’s total housing costs leave almost no cushion for post-closing expenses. For sellers preparing to list, the cost of deferred maintenance is no longer just a lower offer. It is weeks of extra time on the market followed by a price cut that may exceed what the repairs would have cost.
About the Expert: Jean Lewis leads Jean Lewis Homes at Keller Williams Pinnacle, covering the Metro East side of St. Louis, including O’Fallon and Edwardsville, Illinois, and has worked the market for 29 years.
This article is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or investment advice. The views and opinions expressed herein reflect those of the individuals quoted and do not represent an endorsement of any company, product, or service mentioned. Readers should conduct their own due diligence and consult qualified professionals before making any investment decisions.
Explore similar articles from Our Team of Experts.
In most Texas housing markets right now, buyers have leverage they have not enjoyed in years. Inventory is up, prices are softening, and seller concessions – credits toward closing costs or interest-rate buydowns – have become a common negotiating tool. But in the luxury corridors west of Dallas, that playbook stops working above a certain ...
When sellers in the South Bay beach cities need new paint, fresh flooring, or updated landscaping before listing, many resist. They would rather offer the buyer a credit at closing and skip the hassle. It feels logical: give the buyer money to do the work themselves and avoid spending cash on a home you are ...
In small towns where the housing stock is old and buyers are stretching to qualify, a deal’s success often depends on whether the seller is willing to pitch in on repairs. In Chester, Illinois, a Randolph County town where most homes were built decades ago and new construction is scarce, that willingness is now the ...
In the mountain towns around Lake Tahoe, older cabins carry a particular kind of charm – knotty pine walls, stone fireplaces, the look and feel of something that belongs in the Sierra Nevada landscape. They also carry a financial risk that many buyers wildly underestimate, according to Dave Gove, an agent with Real Broker in ...
Buyers considering waterfront property anywhere in Florida tend to treat insurance as a dealbreaker before they have priced it. Along the Gulf Coast’s barrier islands, agents say the difference between an alarming quote and a manageable one often comes down to something surprisingly simple: whether the buyer contacts a national carrier or a local insurer ...
Buyers assume a barrier island in hurricane-prone Southwest Florida must be one of the most expensive places to insure a home. On at least one island near Placida, Florida, the opposite may be closer to the truth – and the reason comes down to elevation and flood zone classification, not marketing. Robin Madden, owner of ...
