After years of weekend sales and bidding wars, well-maintained investment properties in strong Indianapolis neighborhoods are sitting for 30, 60, even 90 days, according to Gloria Gear, a realtor who has worked the city’s investor market for a decade. The shift is catching sellers off guard – especially investor-owners who assumed the fast-moving conditions of recent years were the new normal.
Gear says the current slowdown is something she has never seen in her career. “I’m seeing a lot of days on market creep up – 30, 60, 90 days,” she says.
Prices have not dropped. Gear describes the market as “very stagnant, very flat right now.” That distinction matters for sellers, because flat is not the same as safe. A property that is not losing value on paper can still cost its owner money every month it sits unsold.
Inventory has risen across the metro, giving buyers more choices and less urgency. Gear notes that the rental side is experiencing the same dynamic – more units available, pickier tenants, longer vacancy periods. On the sales side, some properties were priced based on expectations that no longer hold. The post-pandemic era of multiple offers and $15,000 to $20,000 over list price is over.
Price reductions are becoming common, but Gear frames them as a symptom of misaligned expectations rather than a collapsing market. Some sellers priced too high at listing. Others priced reasonably but face a buyer pool with more options and more leverage than it had even a year ago.
Younger renters are also pulling demand away from single-family houses and toward apartment complexes with amenities – gyms, pools, parking. Gear says that shift further softens the tenant pipeline for investor-owners who planned to rent as a fallback. That fallback is still viable, she says, but it may take longer to fill a vacancy than it used to.
Gear currently has two or three clients executing the same pivot: pulling their property off the market and renting it for another year. The logic is straightforward. If a house is not selling at an acceptable price, converting it to a rental preserves the owner’s cash flow, avoids a fire-sale concession, and lets them try again in a different season. As Gear relays it, her clients are saying, “Let’s take it off the market. Let’s rent it for another year.”
Gear also points out that the same conditions hurting sellers are helping buyers. A property that has been listed for 60 or 90 days signals a motivated seller, and Gear encourages her investor-buyers to target those situations. Longer days on market create negotiating room that did not exist when homes sold in a weekend.
One recent deal illustrates how tight those negotiations have become. Gear negotiated a seller from $300,000 down to $260,000 – and the two sides still could not close a $5,000 gap on inspection repairs, killing the transaction entirely.
Gear says sellers should prepare a backup strategy before listing – not after the property has sat for weeks. Knowing in advance whether you can pivot to renting, whether you are willing to accept a price reduction, and what your monthly carrying cost is if the home sits vacant gives you options that reactive sellers do not have.
Indianapolis has not operated in a balanced market during Gear’s entire career. The city’s steady appreciation – she cites a historical norm of 3 to 5 percent annually – has always kept sellers in a comfortable position. That comfort is eroding, even though prices have not dropped. “This is the first time I’m experiencing that,” she says.
Gear says her clients who listed without a backup plan are now scrambling to build one, while the ones who planned for a slow sale are making calm, deliberate decisions. For investor-owners thinking about listing in Indianapolis over the coming months, Gear’s advice is direct: build extra time and flexibility into the plan from the start.
About the Expert: Gloria Gear is an investor-focused agent with Gear RE Group in Indianapolis, who has spent a decade helping out-of-state buyers acquire rentals, flips, and BRRRR properties across the metro.
This article is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or investment advice. The views and opinions expressed herein reflect those of the individuals quoted and do not represent an endorsement of any company, product, or service mentioned. Readers should conduct their own due diligence and consult qualified professionals before making any investment decisions.
Explore similar articles from Our Team of Experts.
Houston’s housing inventory has reached its highest level since 2012. That much supply usually gives buyers more bargaining power and opens doors for investors. But according to Kelvin Louie of KL Integrity Group, many Houston-area sellers bought during the pandemic and paid too much. Values in some areas have since dropped, and these sellers have ...
Houston’s fix-and-flip model thrived after the pandemic, but the numbers no longer add up. Investors want to buy distressed properties, meaning homes that need major repairs, and then renovate and resell them. But they are offering prices so far below what sellers will accept that deals rarely close. According to Tilah Spruel, founder of Lux ...
For decades, construction and trades businesses have operated on a simple model: complete a job, collect payment, find the next one. Revenue arrived in irregular bursts tied to project timelines. That model now works against owners at the moment they most need to show value: when they try to sell. Industry transaction data supports this ...
In Long Beach, California, most homes were not built as tract housing, where a builder puts up many similar homes at once. Instead, homes vary block by block in age, layout, and lot size. That variation makes price per square foot, a metric many investors rely on, a poor guide to whether a deal actually ...
Some small investors in Illinois are moving away from long-term rentals. The reason isn’t weak numbers. It’s the legal risk of renting to tenants in the state. In Chicago’s far northwest suburbs, cities like Elgin and McHenry look like strong rental markets on paper. Home prices are affordable, many residents rent rather than own, and ...
Dearborn Heights, a city of about 63,000 residents in western Wayne County, borders both Dearborn and Detroit. Buyers choosing between neighborhoods in Dearborn Heights are sorting themselves into two distinct tiers. One tier is driven by school districts and parks. The other is driven by rental income and affordability. As the market calms, the difference ...
