School Districts, Commuter Access, Tight Inventory: Why New Jersey's Somerset County Remains a Sellers' Stronghold

Written by:

Steve Marcinuk

Date:

05 May 2026

Share

Share via Facebook

Share via Linkedin

Share via X

Copy to clipboard

National headlines about a cooling housing market may be accurate in parts of the country, but they don’t reflect what is happening on the ground in New Jersey’s Somerset County. While markets like Phoenix, Austin, and Chicago have experienced notable corrections, this corner of the Northeast has remained firmly in seller’s market territory, and the structural reasons behind that resilience show no signs of weakening.

“People read national headlines and think that we’re like Phoenix or Austin or Chicago, and we’re not,” says Jennifer Blanchard, sales associate/team lead at The Blanchard Team with BHHS Fox & Roach Realtors who has been selling in the Somerset County area for 24 years. “In the Northeast, we are squarely in a seller’s market.”

Structural Advantages Market

Part of what makes Somerset County resilient is its geography. Within roughly an hour, residents can access mountain terrain, ski slopes, beaches, and Manhattan. That combination of lifestyle flexibility and commuter convenience has consistently attracted buyers, and the return-to-office trend has reinforced rather than undermined demand.

“During COVID, a lot of people moved out this way because they didn’t have to go to the city all the time,” Blanchard notes. “Now that they have to go back, they’re happy they didn’t go too far away.”

School district quality adds another layer. Within Somerset County, pricing and competition vary meaningfully by town, with top-rated districts like Basking Ridge commanding a premium over neighboring Bridgewater, which in turn sits above Hillsborough on the affordability scale. For buyers weighing options, school ratings function as a built-in market segmentation tool.

Inventory Compression and the Move-Up Squeeze

The most persistent challenge shaping the market is a lack of available homes. Inventory has remained tight for years, and the conditions driving that constraint show no signs of easing. The rate lock-in effect, where homeowners with sub-3% mortgages are reluctant to sell and take on a higher rate, applies unevenly across buyer types.

Blanchard explains that the lock-in primarily affects move-up buyers who would need to sell a home with favorable financing and borrow again at today’s rates. Many are choosing to stay put rather than absorb the cost difference. Downsizers, by contrast, are less constrained. Many have paid off their mortgages entirely or are moving into situations where they would not need to borrow again, making the rate conversation largely irrelevant for that segment. That distinction matters because it shapes which price points are seeing the most activity and where inventory is most compressed.

Move-up buyers, caught between wanting to sell and needing to compete without a contingency, are the most active yet most challenged segment. Some lenders are offering creative structuring to help these buyers move forward, including underwriting approaches that temporarily exclude an existing mortgage from the debt-to-income calculation when a primary residence is actively listed. Combined with deferred first-payment windows of 45 to 90 days after closing, these tools give move-up buyers time to sell their existing home and bring proceeds to the table without carrying two mortgages simultaneously.

Pricing Strategy in a Competitive Market

With well-priced homes still generating multiple offers, the conversation about listing strategy has become more nuanced. Blanchard is direct about what separates properties that move quickly from those that linger: accurate pricing from the start.

Homes sitting at 30, 60, or 90 days on market are not necessarily unsellable — they are, in her view, almost always mispriced. “Buyers aren’t seeing the value,” she says. “And when they don’t get that in the first two weeks, if sellers wait too long and don’t adjust, that’s when buyers start asking, ‘What’s wrong with it?'”

Her approach runs counter to the instinct many sellers have to leave room for negotiation. Listing with built-in wiggle room signals weakness rather than flexibility, she argues. The better strategy is to price at a number the seller would genuinely accept, attract broad attention, and let competition among buyers push the price up. “Once you tell a buyer to make an offer and negotiate, you just lost all your leverage,” she says.

One assumption she regularly pushes back on is that cash offers automatically win. In a market where financed buyers are well-qualified, and pre-approvals from established lenders are reliable, sellers are often willing to accept a higher financed offer over a lower cash one. “A seller would rather take a higher number even if it’s with a mortgage,” she says. “If the mortgage is going to close, the risk is worth it.”

Commission Changes and Industry Adjustments

The structural changes that took effect in August 2024, requiring buyer agency agreements and introducing new commission transparency requirements, have added complexity to transactions. Nearly two years on, the industry is still adjusting.

Blanchard notes that for buyers unfamiliar with previous norms, the new requirements are straightforward to explain. The greater challenge lies with experienced buyers who now face potential commission costs they didn’t encounter before. For agents who treat real estate as a full-time business rather than a side activity, the transition has been manageable, if not entirely smooth. Those most at risk, in her view, are agents who were never deeply engaged with the mechanics of their practice to begin with.

Technology and Search Visibility

As AI-driven search tools like ChatGPT and Claude become more common entry points for consumers researching homes, Blanchard is reworking her team’s web presence and property descriptions to be discoverable through those channels.

“People are searching differently,” she notes. “Our website has to be different so that it gets pulled up. Our property descriptions need to be different so that we make sure our clients’ homes are getting the most exposure possible.”

Looking Ahead

On the macro level, Blanchard is watching industry consolidation, ongoing debates over commission structures, and broader economic uncertainty, but she does not expect any of these forces to alter Somerset County’s market character in the near term. The underlying drivers, school quality, commuter access, lifestyle appeal, and compressed inventory, remain intact.

Whatever economic or geopolitical noise surrounds the housing market, she points to a consistent truth: people always need to move. Life events like growing families, retirements, divorces, and career changes reliably generate transactions regardless of conditions. The variable is pace and volume, not demand itself.

In Somerset County, at least for now, both volume and velocity remain firmly on the seller’s side.

About the Expert: Jennifer Blanchard is the team lead of The Blanchard Team at Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Fox & Roach, Realtors, with 24 years of experience selling real estate in Somerset County, New Jersey.

This article is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or investment advice. The views and opinions expressed herein reflect those of the individuals quoted and do not represent an endorsement of any company, product, or service mentioned. Readers should conduct their own due diligence and consult qualified professionals before making any investment decisions.