For much of the past several years, buyers in northwestern New Jersey were willing to overlook long inspection punch lists and compete aggressively just to secure a home. That dynamic is starting to reverse, according to Radina Vilasco, a real estate agent with Weichert Realtors in Roxbury, New Jersey.
Vilasco says the change has taken hold over the past few months. With less competition from other buyers, her clients are canceling contracts over inspection findings, negotiating on closing costs again, and taking more time to decide. “It was a seller’s market; now it’s becoming more of a balanced market,” she says, adding that some areas may begin “tipping towards a buyer’s market.” In some communities, she adds, buyers now have a good amount of inventory to choose from.
The change reflects a broader shift. Mortgage rates have climbed over the past year, and buyers nationwide are backing out of deals more often than at any point in nearly three years. In New Jersey, more sellers are cutting asking prices, a sign that the leverage that belonged to sellers since the pandemic is starting to move back toward buyers.
Inspections Now End Deals
During the seller’s market, buyers who finally got an offer accepted were reluctant to press on inspection findings. Vilasco says that a year or two ago, when rates were lower and competition was intense, buyers routinely let long repair lists slide. “Even though their inspector would find a long punch list of things that needed to be fixed, they were willing to kind of overlook it because they were just so happy to finally be able to get a house in the competitive market,” she says.
With more options available, buyers are now holding firm. “They are pretty firm on wanting the seller to address them, and in some cases if the seller is not able to address them, maybe can’t afford to address them or doesn’t want to address them, then we are seeing them actually walk away and terminate the contract,” Vilasco says.
That leverage also changes what buyers expect from a listing. Vilasco says a home now needs to be well priced, in good condition, and in a good location to draw strong offers. “We’re not in the type of market where the buyers are just going to be lining up no matter what anymore,” she says.
Lake Fees Strain Budgets
Lake communities add another layer to the region’s affordability picture. Buyers drawn to lake living, whether for a weekend getaway, a summer home, or a full-time residence away from the hustle of a busier area, tend to take their time and shop for something specific, and rising carrying costs are making that search harder.
Fees are a big part of it. Some lake communities have no mandatory HOA, and some lake clubs charge only a few hundred dollars a year. Others carry far higher costs. At Lake Mohawk in Sparta, which Vilasco places among the most expensive lake communities in the area, annual association fees run roughly $2,200 to $3,000. On top of higher mortgage payments, those costs are pushing some buyers away. “To add those fees on top of that makes it challenging and out of the budget for some buyers,” Vilasco says.
Dual Listings Signal Urgency
Some properties in the area are being listed for sale and for rent at the same time, and Vilasco has handled such listings herself. In her experience, the seller is often an investor who has bought and renovated a home and needs to recover that capital quickly. “They need to get their money one way or another,” she says. Those sellers take whichever comes first: a suitable tenant or a buyer at their asking price.
Homeowners sometimes do the same when they are already under contract on a new home and need to sell or rent their current one quickly.
The renters filling those homes tend to be a different profile from today’s buyers, according to Vilasco. Many are not yet ready to purchase, whether because they are still deciding where to settle, saving for a down payment, or working toward qualifying for a mortgage.
Buyers Negotiate Closing Costs
Among entry-level buyers, closing cost requests are back in offers. “Definitely, closing costs are something that we are seeing buyers try to negotiate again,” Vilasco says. As the market tilts toward buyers, those requests have become a way to make purchases more affordable.
Repair requests tied to inspection findings are rising alongside them. “If they’re at the point where they’re paying top dollar for a house, they’re no longer willing to accept some of the maintenance issues that come with it,” Vilasco says. “They’re much quicker to cancel the contract and walk away.”
Looking Past the Holidays
Vilasco notes that the usual holiday slowdown is layering on top of the rate-driven pullback, making it hard to separate seasonal patterns from longer-term change. Together, she says, they have put “a little bit of a freeze” on buyer activity, though she hopes it will pick up after the holidays.
She does not see the shift as cause for alarm. The market is becoming “a little more in favor of the buyers, which isn’t necessarily a bad thing,” she says. It is simply different from what the area has known “since COVID times in 2020 when things really started heating up.”
For buyers who struggled to get offers accepted in recent years, that means more choice and more room to negotiate, including the option to walk away when a home does not measure up.
About the Expert: Radina Vilasco is a real estate agent with Weichert Realtors in Roxbury, New Jersey, working with buyers and sellers across northwestern New Jersey.
This article is based on information provided by the expert source cited above. It is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or real estate advice. Readers should conduct their own research and consult qualified professionals before making any real estate or financial decisions.