The Right Shore House Is Closer Than You Think - And Uglier Than You Expected

Written by:

Heather Hook

Date:

28 May 2026

KeyCrew Studio

Share

Share via Facebook

Share via Linkedin

Share via X

Copy to clipboard

There is a version of house hunting that most buyers don’t realize they’re doing. They walk into a home, see something they don’t like: the cabinet color, the cluttered layout, the missing amenity, and mentally cross it off the list before they’ve spent five minutes inside.

Carly Ringer, a residential real estate agent with Keller Williams Spring Lake on the Central Jersey Shore, has made a skill out of slowing that process down. A big part of her job, she says, is helping buyers separate what is actually a dealbreaker from what is a Saturday morning and a can of paint.

Furniture You Don’t Own Is Not the House

One of the most common reasons buyers check out of a showing early is someone else’s furniture. The sectional is the wrong color. The dining set feels cramped. The bedroom is set up in a way that doesn’t match how they live.

What’s wrong with this picture? None of that furniture comes with the house.

Ringer walks buyers through a specific exercise when this happens. “Where would you put the couch?” she asks. “If you know someone who likes to do yoga, I’ll point out that this room could be perfect, the sun comes in this way, it faces east.” The goal is to get the buyer out of the seller’s version of the home and into their own.

Sometimes she asks them to sit down. If there’s a couch in the room, sit on it for a few minutes. Watch a football game mentally. Picture a movie night with the family. The question she wants buyers to ask themselves is whether the house makes sense for their lives, not whether they like the seller’s couch.

Cosmetic Issues Are Not Structural Problems

Pink walls, dark cabinets, dated tile; these things read as problems during a showing because buyers are seeing the home at its worst. They aren’t seeing what it becomes after a weekend project.

Ringer’s approach with a hesitant buyer is to reframe what they’re looking at. If a room is painted bright pink, she’ll ask whether painting it a neutral color would change how they feel about the space. That shift, from what the room is to what it could be, changes the calculation.

The same logic applies to kitchen cabinets. Buyers frequently pass on kitchens because they wanted white and got oak, or they wanted open shelving and got upper cabinets. Painting cabinets is a real solution. Changing a backsplash is a real solution. These are not complicated renovations. They are cosmetic fixes that buyers often treat as dealbreakers because they’re looking at the house as it is, not as it could be.

The More Sophisticated Version: Finding Workarounds

Beyond furniture and paint, there is a more nuanced skill involved in reading a home’s structure and identifying what can be reconfigured.

Ringer recently worked with clients looking at a beach bungalow that had no washer or dryer, a genuine gap. But the home had a vestibule at the entry, and on the other side of the vestibule wall was a bathroom. The plumbing and electrical systems were already there. Ringer suggested converting the vestibule into a mudroom with a laundry setup, a practical addition that would also give the buyers a place to drop sandy shoes after a day at the beach.

That is a different kind of vision: not painting over a problem, but identifying that the infrastructure to solve it already exists, at a manageable cost.

The same thinking applies to other common objections. No gas stove? A gas line can be run into the house. Solar panels the buyer doesn’t want? They can potentially be negotiated out of the deal, ask the seller to have them removed before closing, especially if the panels have been making the home harder to sell. An extra bedroom can replace a garage when the buyer doesn’t actually need one for a car.

When to Know It’s Actually a Dealbreaker

Not everything is fixable. The bedroom count is close to non-negotiable for families with children. Outdoor space matters in ways that are hard to work around. And some structural issues are simply too costly to absorb.

The point isn’t to talk buyers into a home that doesn’t fit them. It’s to make sure they’re not walking away from the right house for the wrong reasons, because they couldn’t see past someone else’s taste, or because they didn’t know that what they thought was missing was one phone call to a plumber away from being solved.

You can explore what’s currently available on the Central Jersey Shore and get a sense of where opportunity might be hiding in plain sight.

Carly Ringer is a residential real estate agent with Keller Williams Spring Lake, serving buyers and sellers across Monmouth and Ocean County on the Central Jersey Shore. She brings a background in marketing, economics, and entrepreneurship to every transaction.

This article is based on information provided by the expert source cited above. It is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or real estate advice. Readers should conduct their own research and consult qualified professionals before making any real estate or financial decisions.

Disclosure: Individuals or companies mentioned may have a commercial relationship with KeyCrew.