Sarasota, Florida's Housing Market Is Normalizing – And Long-Time Agents Say That's a Good Sign

Written by:

Alejandra Rodriguez

Date:

12 Jun 2026

Share

Share via Facebook

Share via Linkedin

Share via X

Copy to clipboard

After several years of pandemic-fueled frenzy, Florida’s Gulf Coast real estate market is settling into something more familiar to long-time practitioners. In Sarasota, that correction is being felt across price points and property types. For those who have worked the market through multiple cycles, it reads less like a slowdown and more like a return to form.

Matt Cannon, Team Leader of The Cannon Team, – a husband-and-wife team led by Matt and Jenny Cannon – has been working in real estate for over three decades, including more than 22 years in the Sarasota market. He describes the current environment as comparable to 2017 – a market where supply and demand are roughly in balance. “Things are still moving; you just have to be priced properly,” he says.

That balance represents meaningful stability for a region that spent the better part of three years operating in conditions most professionals openly describe as unsustainable. With inventory normalizing and buyer urgency fading, the market is now testing whether its fundamentals can sustain activity without the artificial pressure of the pandemic era.

Why Sarasota Draws Buyers

Part of what makes Sarasota resilient is the breadth of what it offers. The market draws from a wide geographic pool, with buyers arriving from the Northeast, Midwest, Texas, California, and increasingly the Pacific Northwest. The region sits alongside seven barrier islands, each with its own character, and supports a cultural infrastructure that includes eight live performing arts venues, an opera, a symphony, a ballet, and an orchestra.

Cannon notes that the area combines big-city amenities with a small-town feel – a combination that continues to attract retirees, remote workers, and second-home buyers who want urban conveniences without the density.

The buyer profile is varied. Some start on the waterfront keys and eventually migrate downtown for walkability. Others gravitate toward Lakewood Ranch, a master-planned community of roughly 35,000 acres with its own hospitals, retail, and entertainment. Each corridor serves a different lifestyle, and buyers tend to move between them as their circumstances change rather than leave the market altogether.

Pricing Discipline Dominates Now

The most consistent theme in Cannon’s day-to-day work is resetting seller expectations. During the pandemic years, properties moved with minimal friction and above-market pricing was routinely rewarded. That is no longer the case.

“You can’t decide that you want to price over the market because that’s not where the market is,” Cannon explains. “Whatever you sell it for, if something’s remarkably similar, you’re going to sell it for similar to that.”

Properties that have lingered tend to share a common history: they came to market too high, failed to adjust quickly, and accumulated days on market that made buyers skeptical. The correction, when it comes late, is harder to recover from. Cannon’s advice is straightforward – price adjustments should happen promptly and in step with comparable sales, not as a last resort.

Condition is the second major factor separating fast-moving listings from slow ones. Buyers relocating from other states have little appetite for renovation projects. Move-in ready properties, regardless of price tier, are consistently outperforming those that require work. “People don’t want to have to come in and try to redo everything,” Cannon says.

Condo Market: Steadier Than Headlines

Florida’s condominium sector has received considerable national attention over the past two years, driven by new reserve requirements and rising insurance costs following the Surfside collapse. The narrative has outpaced the nuance.

Cannon offers a more measured read. The reserve requirements primarily affect buildings approximately 20 years old or older, and the industry has had time to work toward compliance. On insurance, the picture has improved. Some 20 new private insurers have entered the Florida market since laws were modified to lessen widespread litigation, drawing carriers back into the state. “We’re seeing more of a balancing on the insurance side versus the spikes that we’ve seen in recent years,” Cannon says.

That does not mean the condo market is without friction. Buyers are asking more questions about association finances, pending assessments, and project timelines before making offers. Cannon’s team addresses this proactively, treating association documentation as a standard part of listing preparation rather than something surfaced during due diligence.

Builder Incentives, Structured Carefully

New construction has remained active across the Sarasota region, with inventory available on the keys, downtown, and in Lakewood Ranch. Builders – particularly the larger publicly traded nationals – are offering incentives, but deploying them in ways that protect appraised values.

Rather than cutting list prices, which would drag down comparable sales for existing inventory, builders offer closing cost credits, design center allowances, and lot premium reductions. Cannon explains that they maintain price levels to ensure appraisals hold, while directing negotiating room into other categories.

The publicly traded builders face particular pressure to move inventory on a quarterly basis, which makes them more aggressive than smaller custom builders. For buyers working with nationals, understanding where negotiating room actually exists is a practical advantage.

The Case for Cash Markets

Sarasota’s status as a significant cash market gives it insulation from interest rate sensitivity that purely mortgage-dependent markets lack. A meaningful share of transactions involve buyers liquidating assets from other markets, selling primary residences in higher-cost states, or deploying capital from investment portfolios.

For investors, Cannon sees the clearest opportunity in medium-term holds rather than quick flips – perhaps one to five years, using the property as a rental during the hold period. The rental market is strong enough to generate returns, and underlying demand supports price appreciation over time.

The common mistake he sees among outside investors is applying performance metrics from underperforming Florida markets – such as parts of Cape Coral that saw sharper corrections – to Sarasota. “Sometimes people generalize things and say, ‘I can get this great deal, I’m going to get it for way under.’ That’s not reality,” Cannon says.

Looking Ahead

Several factors could shape Sarasota’s trajectory over the next 12 to 18 months. A proposed tax incentive on the November 2026 ballot, if passed, could encourage more buyers to establish primary residency in the area, adding another layer of demand. Emerging corridors like Ellenton Parish, where two hospitals and a college branch are in development, are beginning to attract attention from buyers looking to get ahead of infrastructure growth.

On interest rates, Cannon takes a long view. Having entered the business when rates were in the high single digits, he is skeptical of buyers waiting for conditions to improve before acting. “Prices are still going to go up,” he says. “Which would you rather do – lock in now at a lower price, or wait a year and pay a higher price at a higher rate?”

After several years of operating at a breakneck pace, Sarasota’s market is functioning more traditionally again. Inventory has improved, buyers are more selective, and pricing discipline matters. While the pace has moderated from pandemic highs, the region’s long-term fundamentals like lifestyle appeal, migration trends, and limited coastal inventory continue to support demand. In this environment, preparation, local expertise, and realistic pricing have become more important than momentum alone.

About the Expert: Matt Cannon is the Team Leader of The Cannon Team, with over three decades of experience in the Sarasota real estate market.

This article is based on information provided by the expert source cited above. It is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or real estate advice. Readers should conduct their own research and consult qualified professionals before making any real estate or financial decisions.