In Chicago, Low Inventory and Steady Appreciation Have Outlasted Multiple Market Cycles

Written by:

Alejandra Rodriguez

Date:

07 Jul 2026

Share

Share via Facebook

Share via Linkedin

Share via X

Copy to clipboard

As housing markets across the Sun Belt have cycled through sharp run-ups and subsequent corrections since 2020, the Chicagoland market has followed a notably different path. While cities like Phoenix, Nashville, and Tampa drew waves of remote workers and saw prices surge well beyond sustainable levels, Chicago absorbed post-pandemic demand more gradually, producing steady price appreciation that has held up across multiple market cycles. For professionals working the market daily, that consistency has created a more predictable operating environment than much of the rest of the country.

Sam Lubeck, team leader of The Lubeck Group at Baird & Warner, has been working the Chicagoland market for 19 years and operates across more than 80 communities. His read on why Chicago behaved differently comes down to a structural difference in how demand moved after COVID. Unlike Sun Belt markets where prices surged and then plateaued or declined, Chicago saw workers return to offices more steadily, which tempered the kind of speculative buying that drove rapid appreciation elsewhere.

“Chicago has seen a consistent increase in overall home prices since COVID over the last six years, a steady incline, and that’s rare compared to the rest of the country,” Lubeck says.

Tight Inventory, Competitive Conditions

That steady appreciation has not translated into an easy market for buyers. Inventory remains the dominant constraint, particularly along the North Shore, where towns from Lake Forest to Wilmette continue to draw strong demand from families seeking access to well-regarded school districts.

“The North Shore inventory is incredibly tight, which means it’s incredibly competitive,” Lubeck notes. “Anytime a quality house comes up that is priced somewhat correctly and is somewhat updated, you’re going to get multiple offers.”

The timing pressure is real and seasonal. With the school year as a hard deadline, families looking to establish residency in a new district need to be under contract by early July. That window concentrates buyer activity and sharpens competition in an already supply-constrained market.

For buyers navigating repeated multiple-offer situations, the emotional toll is measurable. Lubeck describes bidder fatigue as a genuine challenge, particularly for those newer to the market. His approach is direct: prepare clients for competitive conditions from the start and remind them that they have no control over what another buyer is willing to offer.

What Sellers Are Getting Right and Wrong

On the seller side, the market is rewarding accurate pricing and penalizing optimism. Properties that are reasonably updated and priced to reflect actual conditions are moving quickly. Those that enter at aspirational prices are sitting, even in a low-inventory environment.

Lubeck is blunt about where price reductions are occurring; they happen exclusively when sellers overprice. “With limited inventory, it’s all about price,” he says. “If they’ve priced it too high, that’s the only time you’re seeing price reductions.”

At the opposite end of the condition spectrum, fully distressed properties are also finding buyers quickly. Investors and flippers are actively pursuing gut-rehab candidates, and that demand is absorbing inventory that might otherwise linger. The middle ground – properties that are neither move-in ready nor blank-canvas opportunities – tends to be where pricing tension is highest.

The City Has Caught Up

One of the more notable recent developments is the narrowing gap between city and suburban market dynamics. For several years following the pandemic, urban condo markets in Chicago lagged behind suburban single-family demand. That gap has largely closed. Well-priced condos in high-rises are now attracting multiple offers, matching the competitive pace that was previously limited to suburban single-family homes.

Investor interest is a significant driver of that urban recovery. Rental prices have risen sharply, making income-producing properties in the city attractive to landlords and smaller investors. Condo units in buildings that permit rentals are particularly in demand, as buyers see them as both a residence option and a future income asset.

Investors Facing a Harder Search

For capital looking to deploy into Chicagoland, the environment is more competitive than many outside the market expect. Lubeck fields inquiries from investors weekly, and his message is consistent: the days of acquiring distressed properties at a meaningful discount are largely behind them.

Even professional flippers are struggling to find viable deals. Winning a distressed property now requires outbidding other investors before the renovation even begins, which compresses margins on the acquisition side. “The companies that do this for a living are having a harder time finding those properties as well,” Lubeck says. Investors entering the market need to account for competitive offer dynamics on the front end, not just renovation costs and exit pricing.

Multigenerational Buying on the Rise

Beyond investor activity, a quieter but growing trend is reshaping what buyers look for in a home. Lubeck points to Wall Street Journal data showing that 12% of single-family home transactions nationally now involve multigenerational households, a pattern he sees reflected in his own deal flow.

“The family unit has gotten so tight, especially since COVID, over the last six years,” he says. “You see more and more people come to this country from places where that’s just the standard, where the grandparents do live with the kids and the parents.”

This is driving demand for flexible floor plans, in-law suites, and properties that can accommodate multiple generations under one roof. For sellers and developers paying attention to buyer preferences, it is a consideration worth building into how properties are presented and configured.

Cutting Through the Noise

One theme that comes up repeatedly in conversations with experienced Chicagoland practitioners is frustration with the quality of real estate information circulating on social media. Lubeck says consumers frequently arrive with expectations shaped by clickbait predictions that prices are about to fall, or that mortgage rates are about to drop, that do not match what is actually happening in the market.

“There are so many people online just trying to get clicks, creating a doom and gloom scenario,” he says. “It’s really easy to get away from the truth.”

For buyers and sellers trying to make decisions based on actual conditions, the gap between what circulates online and what professionals observe on the ground can be significant. In a market like Chicagoland, where conditions vary meaningfully by submarket and property type, that gap has real consequences for how people price, bid, and time their moves.

The broader picture that emerges from Chicagoland in mid-2026 is one of durability. Prices have not spiked to unsustainable levels, but they have not softened either. Inventory is tight across most segments. Demand from both end users and investors remains active. And for buyers willing to move quickly and price competitively, opportunities exist, but the market does not reward hesitation.

About the Expert: Sam Lubeck is team leader of The Lubeck Group at Baird & Warner, with 19 years of experience in the Chicagoland market operating across more than 80 communities.

This article is based on information provided by the expert source cited above. It is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or real estate advice. Readers should conduct their own research and consult qualified professionals before making any real estate or financial decisions.