The math on buying a conventional short-term rental property has gotten worse from both directions. Mortgage rates sit well above their 2021 lows, making it far more expensive to finance a property. Rental revenue, meanwhile, has grown only modestly, and mostly because hosts are charging more per night rather than filling more nights. For individual investors looking to buy a vacation home and list it on Airbnb, the window that was wide open a few years ago has narrowed considerably.
A different segment of the market may be working with different math: purpose-built experiential properties such as glamping structures, airstreams and themed cabins.
Jasper Ribbers, co-founder of Freewyld Foundry, one of a number of companies handling revenue management for larger short-term rental operators, argues that these properties cost less to put on the ground than conventional homes while commanding nightly rates that many traditional houses struggle to match.
The Experiential Lodging Bet
With individual investors largely priced out of conventional purchases, the opportunity has shifted toward better-capitalized players. Ribbers says institutional-scale operators and niche builders are finding opportunity in purpose-built experiential inventory: properties designed to be the destination, not just a place to sleep. He describes operators who have raised between $10 million and $25 million to buy land and build unique lodging concepts. Smaller projects follow the same logic: a sci-fi-themed glamping site in the southwestern Utah desert, for instance, draws travelers for the units themselves rather than for the region.
In his telling, the economics work because prefabricated structures like geodesic domes or airstreams can be placed on land without traditional foundations or full infrastructure buildouts, making them far cheaper to build than conventional homes. A well-designed, well-located dome of about 400 square feet can earn $400 to $500 a night, Ribbers says. A conventional home, he notes, would typically need three or four bedrooms in a high-demand vacation market to reach that rate.
On the demand side, Ribbers points to younger travelers in particular. “They want to stay at a place that really inspires them, that they can share on their Instagram,” Ribbers says. “They don’t want to just stay at some random place.”
Scale Introduces Its Own Complexity
Clustering multiple units on one site opens revenue streams unavailable to a single listing: group stays, workshops, yoga retreats, micro weddings. It also raises planning and demand questions that a standalone Airbnb never faces. Ribbers describes operators with 60 or 70 units in a single location weighing whether to add another 50. “The question becomes, is there enough demand to fill all that extra inventory and to what extent is it going to cannibalize the existing inventory?”
Smaller projects can also run into this kind of friction. A four-cabin property Ribbers co-owns in Idyllwild, California, has postponed plans for additional cabins. According to Ribbers, construction and labor costs have risen, and approvals from local authorities proved harder to secure than expected, and the return on new units would currently be too thin to justify building them.
A Fragmented 2026 Market
Performance across U.S. short-term rental markets has been uneven this year. During the World Cup, nightly rates in the 16 host-city markets jumped while occupancy was flat or down in most of them. Ribbers says local events likely explain some of the variation; college football, for instance, can meaningfully shift demand in certain cities.
Travel from Canada has also fallen: Canadian travel to the U.S. dropped 25% in 2025, with little recovery in early 2026. Ribbers also points to reports of international travelers being detained at airports. “Those stories go around and it creates fear amongst international travelers to travel to the States,” he says.
Those elevated World Cup prices also kept many domestic travelers away from host cities, Ribbers says, while international visitor numbers came in below expectations.
Regulation Before Revenue
For anyone considering entering the space, Ribbers says regulatory due diligence comes first. Limits on rental days, occupancy caps, or a shift in local sentiment can undermine an investment after the purchase. “Regulations are always the first thing you have to look at because you can get really burned,” Ribbers says.
Local sentiment varies widely, he says. In communities with limited economic activity, short-term rentals are often welcomed as a source of visitor spending. In others, opposition is organized and growing. Ribbers, who lives in Spain, points to weeks of protests in Valencia and Barcelona’s plan to phase out all licensed tourist apartments by November 2028. “If you’re buying an STR, it’s a long-term investment, so you want to make sure that you choose your location wisely.”
Three Forces Shaping the Next Year
Ribbers sees three forces shaping the near term: continued demand for distinctive lodging, economic uncertainty pushing travelers toward deals, and AI changing how operators run their businesses. On AI, Ribbers, whose company develops AI tools for operators, frames adoption as close to mandatory for new entrants. “Otherwise I think you’re going to be outcompeted by other companies that do,” he says.
His broader caution is that short-term rentals have matured past the point where simply listing a property produces strong returns. New entrants now face the same questions as any other hospitality business: who the guest is, what the property offers that competitors don’t, and whether the numbers work at today’s financing costs. “Maybe 10 years ago it was easy to just buy a place, put it on Airbnb, and you could do really well,” Ribbers says. “Now it’s more like any other industry where you have to go back to fundamental business principles.”
About the Expert: Jasper Ribbers is Co-Founder and Head of Revenue Management at Freewyld Foundry, based in Spain, where he works with short-term rental operators in the U.S., Canada, and international markets.
This article is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or investment advice. The views and opinions expressed herein reflect those of the individuals quoted and do not represent an endorsement of any company, product, or service mentioned. Readers should conduct their own due diligence and consult qualified professionals before making any investment decisions.