KeyCrew Journal Logo

Affordable Housing's Property Insurance Costs Are Falling. The Relief May Not Last.

Written by:
Date:
16 Nov 2026
Share

For most of the past decade, insurance has been one of the fastest-rising costs of operating affordable housing. Across one Gulf Coast portfolio of tax credit properties, per-unit premiums more than doubled between 2017 and 2023, and New York owners saw the same doubling over an even shorter span. The increases hit properties that run on thin margins and that lenders had underwritten for far smaller insurance budgets, and in some cases they pushed buildings toward insolvency.

That pressure has now eased, at least on the property side. Commercial insurance rates have fallen for nine consecutive quarters, with property leading the decline, and U.S. property pricing dropped by double digits again in the third quarter of 2026. But the relief is cyclical, not structural. Liability coverage for apartment owners remains volatile, the pool of insurers interested in affordable housing remains small, and the next hard market will arrive on its own schedule. What owners do with the current window will shape how well they weather it.

David Robinson, who leads the affordable housing practice group at insurance brokerage Scott Insurance, describes 2017 through 2024 as an exceptionally punishing property market. In that period, he says, premiums doubled, tripled, or even quadrupled for some claims-heavy accounts, and the costs drove several properties, including some owned by large national developers, into financial insolvency.

A Partial Reprieve

The current relief applies to one line of coverage, not to insurance costs as a whole. Insurance cycles move separately by line, and right now property and liability are heading in opposite directions. According to Robinson, most affordable housing owners have seen their property premiums fall for two consecutive years – by double digits last year and by a smaller margin this year, depending on each account’s loss history. Liability is a different story. Robinson calls the current liability market more challenging for habitational risks, and broader market data shows umbrella and excess liability rates still climbing, with apartment buildings among the most volatile segments.

Even the property softening sits on a fragile foundation, because the market’s underlying imbalance hasn’t changed. Robinson says relatively few mid-market carriers have a dedicated strategy for affordable housing, while demand for coverage grows with every new unit built. Regional exposures compound that scarcity: hurricanes drive carrier concern along the Gulf Coast and in the Southeast, while severe convective storms, hail, and tornadoes weigh on the middle of the country. Robinson expects the market to turn again, though no one can predict when. “It’s a great time to take advantage of that and perhaps reinvest some of those savings to prepare for the next hard market,” he says.

Rethinking Risk Financing

Preparing for the next hard market, in Robinson’s view, starts with treating insurance as a form of financing rather than a fixed annual bill. Carriers must price coverage to return a profit to their shareholders, so even a well-priced policy amounts to expensive capital. “They are not charities,” Robinson says.

Owners of affordable housing who can predict and prevent losses can afford to keep more of that risk on their own balance sheets. He compares the logic to a healthy, nonsmoking marathon runner choosing a high-deductible health plan: someone who expects to use less coverage than the average member of the pool gains little from paying for full protection. “Premiums are just a lagging indicator of what’s happened in the months and years leading up to that renewal,” Robinson says. “They’re a lagging indicator of operational discipline.”

Robinson stresses that the approach of keeping more risk in-house doesn’t suit every owner, and that not every portfolio should move immediately into a captive insurer, a company owned by the businesses it covers, or a high-deductible program. Retaining risk works for operators who have already built the internal infrastructure to manage it: clear communication running from executives through property managers and maintenance staff to residents, along with active loss prevention at the property level.

The broader industry has already started moving in this direction. During the hard market, a large share of affordable housing providers raised their deductibles to contain premium increases. New York has gone further, treating insurance costs as a housing-supply problem: the state lent money to a captive insurer owned by affordable housing operators and funded a pilot program to help nonprofit providers use captives, while New York City has proposed a city-backed insurance program for the sector. The underlying shift – from buying coverage to financing risk – extends well beyond any single owner or broker.

Where Deals Break Down

Insurance pressure doesn’t end once a property is operating. It also shapes whether new projects close, because lenders and tax credit syndicators have tightened their insurance requirements. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, for example, have recently imposed stricter general liability standards on multifamily borrowers.

Robinson says the stricter rules protect investors’ money but often shift the cost of risk onto developers. A single deal financed with low-income housing tax credits, especially a wood-frame building, might involve ten different investors, each with its own insurance demands. Some of those demands contradict each other, and some call for coverage that insurers won’t sell at a price the deal can bear.

Robinson describes a recent case in which a government-sponsored enterprise tried to require an affordable housing owner to carry $10 million in liability coverage for assault and battery and for abuse and molestation. Even if that coverage had been available, it would have cost enough to sink the deal. The lender instead required the owner to set aside $50,000 in cash reserves for those claims.

In another case, a national lender set builder’s risk minimums that bore little relation to the project’s actual exposure. The hard-cost requirement exceeded the construction contract by more than a million dollars, and the soft-cost requirement, an arbitrary $5 million, sat several million above what the owner would actually incur after a loss. The lender lowered both once it accepted that a smaller limit would fully cover its capital in a total loss.

“Having a conversation early about what’s the true risk of this project can help make affordable housing projects more profitable and ultimately lead to the construction of more affordable units,” Robinson says.

Supportive Housing’s Narrower Market

If coverage for affordable housing is scarce, coverage for permanent supportive housing, which pairs affordable homes with on-site services for people who have experienced homelessness, often with disabilities, is scarcer still. According to Robinson, carriers worry that vulnerable residents may generate expensive claims, and that concern narrows an already thin market. The need for supportive housing keeps growing regardless, Robinson notes, which leaves owners managing the same pressures as the broader sector with fewer carriers willing to take on the risk.

The same operating principles apply, but the relationship with residents matters even more. When someone is hurt or a home is damaged, the resident can turn to the owner for help or turn to a lawyer. Owners who have built genuine trust through responsive management give residents reasons to choose the first path, and Robinson notes that many mission-driven nonprofit developers already work this way, along with many for-profit owners.

Legal Reform’s Slow Payoff

Liability costs ultimately depend on each state’s legal environment, and changes there take years to reach premiums. Georgia offers a clear example. The American Tort Reform Foundation had ranked the state at or near the top of its annual “Judicial Hellholes” list in recent years, and in April 2025 Georgia enacted a sweeping tort reform package.

Among other changes, the package narrowed negligent-security claims, which hold property owners liable for crimes that third parties commit on their premises – a major exposure for apartment owners. The foundation dropped Georgia from the list in its latest report but placed three Atlanta-area counties on its watch list, and Robinson says the benefits of reform are still working their way into insurance rates.

North Carolina has taken a different route. In June 2026, it became the first state to ban third-party litigation funding outright – the practice of outside investors, such as private equity or hedge funds, financing lawsuits in exchange for a share of any payout. Other states have restricted the practice, but none had prohibited it. “It reintroduces some fairness into the system,” Robinson says, adding that he expects other states to follow. Neither reform will lower liability premiums quickly, though, and for affordable housing owners that delay means liability costs will likely stay elevated even as property costs fall.

Using the Window

Taken together, these pressures explain why the current softening offers affordable housing owners a breathing spell rather than a resolution. Property premiums have come down, but liability costs remain stubborn, the carrier pool remains shallow, and storm and legal exposures haven’t gone away. Robinson argues that the savings from this cycle will matter most for owners who treat them as an opportunity rather than a windfall: investing in loss prevention, reconsidering how much risk they retain, and settling insurance requirements early in a deal rather than at the closing table.

The stakes extend beyond individual portfolios. Insurance costs now shape how many affordable units get financed, how well existing buildings get maintained, and whether marginal properties survive the next downturn, which is why policymakers have begun treating insurance as a housing problem rather than a line item. The next hard market will test whether the industry used this one to change how it carries risk.

About the Expert: David Robinson, Affordable Housing Practice Lead, Scott Insurance, North Carolina.

This article is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or investment advice. The views and opinions expressed herein reflect those of the individuals quoted and do not represent an endorsement of any company, product, or service mentioned. Readers should conduct their own due diligence and consult qualified professionals before making any investment decisions.