The New Map of South Jersey Shore Real Estate: Why Buyers Are Flocking to Overlooked Towns

Written by:

Alejandra Rodriguez

Date:

21 Apr 2026

Share

Share via Facebook

Share via Linkedin

Share via X

Copy to clipboard

If you’re considering a beach house in South Jersey, the landscape has changed — just not in the way most expected. Over the past year, buyers have quietly shifted their attention away from traditional hotspots and toward neighborhoods that were rarely considered just 18 months ago. From Atlantic City to Ventnor, the region’s affordability map is being redrawn as buyers chase value in new places.

For decades, Margate and Longport set the standard for desirable Shore living. But as prices in these towns soared beyond what many families could afford, buyers began expanding their search — first to neighboring areas, then to entirely new markets. Today, local real estate agents say that the next wave of Shore buyers isn’t focused on old favorites; instead, they’re finding opportunity in towns that once flew under the radar.

Margate and Longport Push Buyers Out

Margate was long seen as the accessible choice for families wanting a summer home. That changed as new construction and renovated properties regularly topped $1 million, and even teardowns began commanding what used to be move-in-ready prices. Longport followed the same path, making both towns out of reach for many buyers who still wanted beach access.

Eric Millstein, a longtime South Jersey Shore agent with Soleil Sotheby’s International Realty, explains that buyers in Margate often felt like they were overpaying, but quickly saw their investment rise in value. This persistent demand kept prices high, but also sent a wave of buyers searching for alternatives — many of whom landed in Ventnor.

Ventnor Emerges as a Top Choice

Ventnor quickly became the next destination for buyers priced out of Margate and Longport. Over the past year, the town’s four commercial districts have grown busier, public infrastructure has improved, and new construction has appeared on formerly quiet blocks. While prices have risen, they remain lower than in Margate, attracting both year-round residents and summer families.

Homes in Ventnor that would have lingered on the market a few years ago are now drawing multiple offers. Millstein notes that Ventnor’s ability to attract both seasonal and permanent residents is fueling this demand. Inventory has struggled to keep up, as buyers who once dismissed Ventnor as “not quite there yet” now see it as a smart investment.

Atlantic City’s Neighborhoods Gain Ground

The biggest surprise is Atlantic City’s emergence as a serious residential market — not in the casino district, but in neighborhoods like Bungalow Park, Venice Park, Chelsea Heights, and Ducktown. These areas are seeing new construction, renovations, and a steady influx of first-time buyers who couldn’t afford to live in other Shore towns.

Atlantic City offers a key advantage: lower land costs. This allows builders to deliver new duplexes and single-family homes in the low- to mid-$600,000s — a price point now unattainable in Margate or Longport. Buyers are purchasing these properties as primary residences, Airbnbs, or long-term rentals. Some are choosing to live in one unit and rent out the other to offset their mortgage.

According to Millstein, this shift is making homeownership possible for young families, small investors, and anyone priced out of the traditional Shore markets. “We’re creating affordable housing across the board where it wasn’t available before,” he says.

One Chelsea-area project features bayfront homes with deep-water boat slips for just over $600,000. In other Shore towns, similar properties easily exceed $3 million. The price difference is drawing buyers who want waterfront access without the premium price tag.

Expanding Definition of Affordability

The South Jersey Shore’s definition of “affordable” is no longer limited to a handful of backup towns. Atlantic City and Ventnor have become primary options for a growing number of buyers who want beach proximity and amenities without the steep costs of legacy markets.

Those waiting for prices to fall across the Shore are likely to be disappointed. Home values have not declined; instead, demand has shifted geographically. Buyers who act quickly in these emerging areas are securing properties at prices that still offer value compared to the established markets.

For recent buyers, the news is also positive. Anyone who purchased a Shore property in the past five years is almost certain to see a significant increase in value. The market has not cooled; it has simply spread out, with new pockets of demand driving appreciation in places that once lagged.

What Buyers Need to Know Now

Today’s South Jersey Shore market rewards buyers who are willing to look beyond traditional zip codes and consider neighborhoods with untapped potential. The best values are no longer found by waiting for prices to drop in Margate or Longport, but by identifying where the next wave of demand is building.

Ventnor and Atlantic City’s neighborhoods now offer a mix of new construction, renovated homes, and waterfront access at prices that are increasingly rare elsewhere on the Shore. These towns are attracting not only first-time buyers and young families, but also investors and second-home seekers who recognize the long-term upside.

For sellers, this shift means that properties in once-overlooked areas can now command strong prices — often with multiple offers. For buyers, it’s a reminder that the market’s center of gravity is changing, and those who adapt quickly stand to benefit the most.

Looking Ahead

The South Jersey Shore is experiencing a clear reordering of its real estate hierarchy. As traditional hotspots become less accessible, demand is fueling rapid growth in neighboring towns and previously overlooked neighborhoods. This trend is likely to continue as more buyers prioritize value and long-term potential over legacy status.

For anyone considering a Shore property, the key takeaway is clear: flexibility and a willingness to explore new areas are now essential. The market is not cooling — it’s just moving. Those who recognize this shift early are finding the best opportunities and building equity in places that, until recently, were barely on the map.

About the Expert: Eric Millstein is a Real Estate Associate at Soleil Sotheby’s International Realty, South Jersey Shore. Specializing in new construction, rehabs, secondary homes, and investment properties across Atlantic County.

This article is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or investment advice. The views and opinions expressed herein reflect those of the individuals quoted and do not represent an endorsement of any company, product, or service mentioned. Readers should conduct their own due diligence and consult qualified professionals before making any investment decisions.