Internet Lenders Cause Most Houston Deal Failures as Buyers Chase Low Rates

Written by:

Rudi Davis

Date:

27 Feb 2026

Share

Share via Facebook

Share via Linkedin

Share via X

Copy to clipboard

Financing problems, not appraisal gaps or high rates, have become the leading cause of failed residential real estate deals in Houston. According to Anja Drewes Neidhardt, owner and broker at Anja Drewes Properties, the main culprit is lender incompetence, with critical documentation issues surfacing just days before closing.

Rate Shopping

Houston home sales are increasingly collapsing at the financing stage, Drewes reports, and the issue is not rising rates or low appraisals. Instead, buyers are picking lenders based solely on advertised rates, only to discover late in the process that they cannot meet documentation or qualification requirements.

“Most of the time it’s financing that, in the end, they didn’t get approved,” Drewes says. She notes that during the 2020–2022 market, appraisal gaps were the most common reason for deal failures. Now, properties are appraising at contract prices, but buyers are still losing homes because their financing falls apart — often after receiving pre-approval letters.

The failures are concentrated among buyers who choose internet-based or discount lenders promising low rates. These lenders often skip thorough reviews during pre-approval, leaving major issues undetected until the final underwriting phase.

Drewes describes situations where buyers are lured by “one 800 lending or internet lender who promised them great rates, but then the service is really horrible.” She says problems typically emerge just 2 to 3 days before closing, when underwriters finally review the files and find documentation gaps that should have been addressed at the start.

These late-stage failures disrupt everyone involved. Sellers who have taken their properties off the market and made plans based on the sale face uncertainty and potential financial loss. Buyers risk losing their earnest money deposits and must restart their search. Listing agents are unable to advise buyers on lender selection, leaving a gap in quality control.

Employment Gaps

Most failed deals trace back to employment history or income documentation that was never properly vetted during pre-approval. Drewes says underwriters often discover employment gaps or income verification problems that should have been caught much earlier.

“They didn’t do their homework before that. They didn’t see some income gaps when they had a job in between; something then comes up, really, like two or three days before closing. Like, why wasn’t that tackled before you got the pre-approval letter?” Drewes says.

Discount lenders are issuing pre-approval letters after incomplete file reviews, either to boost application numbers or because their processes lack quality control. Buyers receive pre-approval letters that look legitimate but are based on assumptions or missing documentation — problems that only become apparent during full underwriting.

The risk is highest for buyers with non-traditional income, self-employment, or recent job changes. These situations require careful documentation and analysis up front, but discount lenders often postpone this work, increasing the risk of late-stage deal failures.

Drewes says the problem has grown as buyers focus on rate shopping rather than lender service. Online mortgage platforms make it easy to compare rates, but much harder to evaluate whether a lender conducts thorough pre-approvals.

Listing Agents

Listing agents have little ability to influence which lenders buyers use or to require evidence of thorough pre-approval. Drewes explains that she cannot direct buyers to specific lenders or insist on local companies with a record of reliable service.

“I think most of the time is because of incumbency of lenders working on their file, and I can’t, I mean, I, if I’m the listing agent, I can’t tell them who to use,” Drewes says.

This creates an information gap. Sellers and listing agents must accept pre-approval letters at face value, with no way to verify that the lender has done proper due diligence. When buyers choose lenders based only on rates, the risk of failure is hidden until the deal is underway.

As a result, sellers may become more hesitant to accept offers from buyers using unfamiliar lenders. Some are starting to require larger earnest money deposits or shorter option periods from buyers with internet-based mortgages, in an effort to offset the risk of a failed closing.

The solution, Drewes argues, is better buyer education about the importance of lender quality and the thoroughness of pre-approval. Buyers willing to accept a slightly higher rate from a competent lender are more likely to close successfully, but this message is not being widely communicated in the market.

Appraisal Issues

The rise in lender-related deal failures marks a clear change from the pandemic-era market. Drewes says that appraisal gaps, once the main reason transactions fell through, are now rare in Houston.

Properties are appraising at contract prices because the market has stabilized and prices have leveled off. Houston did not experience the dramatic price inflation seen in some coastal cities, so current appraisals are generally supported by comparable sales.

“We don’t see that because our prices are not blown up here in the Texas market. They are, pretty much they are, they appraise,” Drewes says.

With appraisal risk largely gone, lender competence is now the most visible — and frustrating — obstacle for buyers and sellers. Deals that should close smoothly are instead falling apart over documentation problems that better pre-approval processes would have prevented.

Most of the friction in Houston’s current home sales is self-inflicted, driven by buyers who prioritize the lowest advertised rate over lender reliability. If buyers spent more time evaluating lender service quality and pre-approval standards, deal failures would likely drop, making the market more efficient and reducing costs for everyone involved.

Looking Ahead

As the Houston real estate market stabilizes, the main threat to successful closings is no longer price volatility but the quality of lender due diligence. Buyers who focus only on interest rates expose themselves to last-minute failures that can cost time, money, and opportunity. For sellers, understanding which offers are backed by solid financing has become a key part of risk management. Unless buyer education and lender accountability improve, the pattern of late-stage deal failures is likely to persist, slowing transactions and eroding market trust.