Walk through an open house in Northeast Portland on a Sunday afternoon, and you might see something that’s been rare for a while: a handful of serious buyers, genuine competition, mayb...
In New York City, Apartment Condition Has Become the Deciding Factor for Buyers
Written by:
Date:
02 Jun 2026
Share via Facebook
Share via Linkedin
Share via X
Copy to clipboard
A clear divide is playing out in New York City real estate. Renovated apartments and townhomes are selling quickly, sometimes before the listing goes live. Older units with dated kitchens and tired bathrooms are sitting for weeks, collecting price reductions while sellers struggle to understand what went wrong.
The difference isn’t location or even price. It’s condition. According to Mike Falchiere, founder of The Falchiere Group, a brokerage and construction management firm operating across all five boroughs, most sellers don’t grasp this until it’s too late.
Buyers Want Move-In Ready
Buyers today, whether financing or paying cash, are not interested in projects. They want light, bright, and modern. They want to move in and start living, not start managing contractors.
“There’s definitely a flight to quality,” Falchiere says. “If you have a nicely renovated product, somebody’s always going to pay a premium for that.”
The apartments struggling right now are largely units converted from rental buildings to condos and co-ops during the conversion wave of the 1980s and 1990s. Many haven’t been meaningfully updated since. They’re structurally sound, often in strong buildings and desirable locations, but the finishes are a dealbreaker for today’s buyer.
Why Sellers Keep Overpricing
The pattern repeats constantly: a seller looks at what renovated apartments in their building sold for, assumes their unit is worth the same, and lists accordingly. Showings come in slow. Feedback is polite but consistent; buyers want something updated. The seller waits. Then comes the price reduction.
Price reductions send a signal. Buyers see a price cut and wonder what’s wrong. They lowball. The final sale price ends up lower than it would have been if the seller had priced honestly from the start.
“Overpricing and doing price reductions tend to show lower sales prices overall,” Falchiere says.
The smarter play, he says, is to price correctly from day one, or better yet, to do the renovation first.
How Renovation Changes the Math
When a buyer walks into a property that needs work, they’re not just thinking about the purchase price. They’re mentally adding up renovation costs, contractor headaches, the time they’ll spend without a functional kitchen, and the risk of costs running over. That mental math almost always results in a lowball offer, or no offer at all.
But when a seller presents a fully scoped renovation plan with real cost estimates and a clear picture of the finished apartment, it removes the fear. A buyer who would have passed on a dated two-bedroom can suddenly see the potential, and price it accordingly.
Falchiere notes that many buyers won’t consider renovation projects because of widespread stories about contractors overcharging, walking off jobs, or triggering stop-work orders. “You hear horror stories,” he says. Having a trusted team in place, or at minimum, a realistic renovation estimate, changes the conversation entirely.
What Sellers Should Do Now
Sellers with properties that need work have two practical options. The first is to renovate before listing. Even cosmetic updates, fresh paint, new light fixtures, refinished floors, can meaningfully change how buyers perceive a space. A full kitchen or bathroom renovation in the right building can return significantly more than it costs.
The second option: if you’re not going to renovate, price the apartment to reflect its actual condition, not the condition of the renovated unit down the hall. Work with your broker to get honest market feedback early and be willing to act on it. A small price adjustment in week two is far less damaging than a large one in week six.
What Buyers Should Consider
The dated apartments sitting on the market right now are often in excellent buildings in desirable locations. If buyers can secure a reliable renovation estimate before making an offer, they’re in a strong negotiating position, potentially buying into a neighborhood at a discount compared to what the finished product would cost.
Buyers should ask upfront whether their broker has construction management resources or contractor relationships. That kind of integrated support can turn a daunting project into a manageable one.
Looking Ahead
This divide between renovated and unrenovated properties is unlikely to narrow anytime soon. As more updated inventory sells and older units remain, the gap in sale prices and days on market will likely widen further. Sellers who wait to act, either by renovating or by adjusting their price expectations, risk watching their equity erode through repeated reductions and extended market time. For buyers who can take on a project with the right support, the current surplus of dated inventory is a window that may not stay open indefinitely.
About the Expert: Mike Falchiere is the founder and licensed real estate salesperson at The Falchiere Group in New York City, specializing in full-service brokerage and construction management across all five boroughs, New Jersey, and Westchester County.
This article is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or investment advice. The views and opinions expressed herein reflect those of the individuals quoted and do not represent an endorsement of any company, product, or service mentioned. Readers should conduct their own due diligence and consult qualified professionals before making any investment decisions.
Similar Articles
Explore similar articles from Our Team of Experts.
