Fixer-Uppers Stall While Lakefront Holds Strong in Ithaca's 2026 Market

Written by:

Alejandra Rodriguez

Date:

05 Jun 2026

Share

Share via Facebook

Share via Linkedin

Share via X

Copy to clipboard

If you’re house hunting in Ithaca right now, you’ve probably noticed something strange. Some homes disappear within days of hitting the market. Others, even ones priced reasonably, sit there. It’s not random. There’s a clear pattern emerging, and knowing which side of it you’re on could save you a lot of time and money.

Linda Santos, a licensed associate real estate broker with Warren Real Estate Downtown, has been watching this split play out across the Ithaca market through the first half of 2026. Inventory is up significantly; new listings jumped 27.5 percent year-to-date through April, but not everything that’s listed is selling.

The Market in Plain English

More homes are available right now than Ithaca buyers have seen in years. But the extra inventory hasn’t made every home easier to sell. Instead, it has made the buyers pickier. They have more to compare, more time to think, and, for the first time in a while, more room to negotiate.

Average days on market have nearly doubled, from 14 days in 2025 to 28 days in 2026. But that average hides a real divide: some homes are still gone in days, while others are quietly collecting dust.

Move-In Ready Wins Every Time

The single biggest driver of a fast sale in Ithaca right now is condition. Turnkey homes, updated, clean, needing little to no work, are still attracting strong interest and can draw competing offers.

The reason comes down to a very local problem: finding a good contractor in Ithaca is hard. Quality tradespeople are booked out, and prices have become eye-watering. Santos noted that buyers looking to add just one bathroom are now getting quotes of $70,000 or more. “It is not easy in this community to find and schedule the quality of repair people,” she said. Numbers like that are enough to make a move-in-ready home feel like a deal, even at a premium price.

Homes with updated kitchens, functioning systems, and no obvious deferred maintenance are the ones getting attention. Buyers are busy, costs are high, and the appetite for taking on a project has shrunk.

Fixer-Uppers and Multi-Family Properties

On the other end of the spectrum, homes that need work are sitting on the market significantly longer. With renovation costs where they are, buyers are doing the math and walking away. A home priced at $380,000 that needs $70,000 in updates doesn’t feel like a bargain: it feels like a trap.

Multi-family properties are facing their own reckoning. When Santos reviewed her office’s multi-family inventory from roughly a year ago, about half of those listings hadn’t sold. Landlords who haven’t kept their properties in good shape are finding buyers unwilling to take on the risk at current prices, especially with property taxes among the highest in the state. “The profit margin seems to have evaporated for multi-families that we used to see selling very easily,” she said.

The Luxury and Lake Exception

While the middle of the market sorts itself out, the higher end is holding up well. Santos pulled fresh data on lakefront sales across Cayuga and Seneca Lakes: 126 properties sold in the past year at an average closed price of $819,000, with an average price per square foot of $509. There are currently 30 active lake listings ranging from $257,000 for a small camp up to $3.295 million. A $7 million lakefront home recently hit the market, the highest-priced single-family listing ever seen on Cayuga Lake.

“The desirability of the lake properties does not seem to be waning at the moment,” Santos said.

What You Should Do Now

If you’re buying, focus your search on move-in-ready homes, even if they cost more upfront. Factor in what it would actually cost to update a fixer-upper before you make an offer: the numbers may surprise you. If a home has been sitting for more than three weeks, you have real negotiating power. Ask for an inspection, request repairs, and don’t be afraid to come in under the asking price.

If you’re selling, condition is everything right now. If your home needs updates, consider offering a credit toward repairs rather than trying to price around the problem. Buyers are doing the math, and a realistic price from day one will outperform an optimistic one that sits for weeks. If your home is already in great shape, lean into it: that’s your strongest selling point in this market.

If you’re a small investor, Multi-family properties in Ithaca are a tougher play than they were a few years ago. Santos suggests considering higher-quality turnkey rentals or condominiums rather than older stock that needs significant work. The margins on mid-range fixer-uppers have gotten thin.

About the Expert: Linda Santos is a licensed associate real estate broker with Warren Real Estate Downtown in Ithaca, New York. She works across residential, multi-family, and lakefront segments of the Finger Lakes market, with particular focus on the conditions shaping buyer and seller decisions in the current cycle.

This article is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or investment advice. The views and opinions expressed herein reflect those of the individuals quoted and do not represent an endorsement of any company, product, or service mentioned. Readers should conduct their own due diligence and consult qualified professionals before making any investment decisions.