Cape Cod Homes Are Sitting Longer – But It’s Not the Rates

Written by:

Alejandra Rodriguez

Date:

27 Apr 2026

Share

Share via Facebook

Share via Linkedin

Share via X

Copy to clipboard

If you’ve been watching Cape Cod real estate and wondering why so few homes are selling, you’re not alone. Across the region, transaction volume has dropped to historic lows — but not for the reason most people assume.

While mortgage rates are higher than they were a few years ago, the main issue is a severe shortage of available homes. Inventory has reached record lows, and buyers have little to choose from.

Right now, Cape Cod has just 494 active listings out of 130,000 single-family homes — only 0.38% of the market is available for purchase. Before the pandemic, about 2% to 2.5% of homes would turn over each year. This year, turnover is on track to be closer to 1%, making it one of the tightest markets in recent memory.

“People are frozen in place,” says Jack Bohman, lead agent and co-founder of The Bohman Hartung Group at Gibson Sotheby’s International Realty in Chatham. He notes that many homeowners are holding onto their low mortgage rates and have little incentive to move.

But higher rates aren’t the only factor keeping homes off the market.

Why Cape Cod Inventory Is Low

Three persistent factors are restricting supply across the Cape — and none show signs of easing.

First, there’s almost no vacant land left for development. Builders can’t create new subdivisions as they might in other regions. To construct a new home, developers typically have to buy an existing property, tear it down, and rebuild. This drives up the cost of new construction, especially in towns like Chatham, where even homes without water views can now cost over $4 million to build.

“Before COVID, no house without a water view in Chatham ever sold for over $2.5 million,” Bohman says. Now, non-water-view homes are selling for over $4 million, simply because that’s the only way to get a new house.

Second, older homeowners are staying put much longer. Strict zoning laws have made it nearly impossible to build new assisted living facilities, and the few that exist are prohibitively expensive. Many longtime residents are aging in place and hiring in-home care rather than downsizing or moving into senior housing. This means fewer homes are being listed, compared with what was once a steady source of inventory.

Third, the pandemic-era surge of refinancing at ultra-low rates has locked many owners in place. Homeowners with mortgages at 2% or 3% are reluctant to sell and take on a new loan at 6% or 7%. Even those who want to upgrade or relocate are deterred by the higher monthly payments, deepening the inventory crunch.

What Buyers Are Facing

For buyers, the shortage is immediate and frustrating. Bohman’s team has a long list of clients ready to purchase, but few homes to show them. Most buyers aren’t waiting for prices to fall — they’re prepared to act, but find nothing suitable on the market.

When a well-priced, recently renovated home is listed, it sells quickly, often with multiple offers. In contrast, fixer-uppers are lingering. Many Cape Cod buyers have already managed a renovation in the Boston suburbs and are unwilling to take on another project 90 miles away, especially without established connections to local contractors.

“A house that’s been renovated and priced appropriately will have a lot of buyers,” Bohman says. “A fixer-upper, not so much.”

The renovation hurdle is significant. Spending more than 50% of a home’s assessed value on improvements triggers a requirement to bring the entire property up to current building codes, including FEMA flood standards. This can mean raising the house and installing a new foundation, adding tens of thousands of dollars to the project. For many, the cost and complexity outweigh the potential benefits.

What This Means

If you’re trying to buy on Cape Cod, be prepared to move quickly when a desirable property comes to market — and expect to pay a fair price. Lowball offers rarely succeed in this environment. Buyers may have better luck with homes that need cosmetic updates but have solid construction and a good location. However, any major renovation could trigger expensive code compliance requirements.

For sellers, this is a favorable time to list, especially if your home is updated and move-in ready. With so little competition, well-presented homes still attract strong interest and multiple offers. If your property needs work, pricing it realistically is essential, as buyers are unwilling to take on large projects unless the discount justifies the effort.

Those waiting for a significant price drop are likely to be disappointed. Cape Cod’s strict zoning regulations and limited buildable land create durable barriers to new supply, which help support home values even during market slowdowns. Prices may flatten or dip slightly, but a major correction is unlikely under current conditions.

The Bottom Line

Cape Cod’s real estate slowdown is driven by a lack of supply, not just higher interest rates. With so few homes available and many buyers waiting, the market remains gridlocked. “There’s a lot of pent-up demand in the system,” Bohman says. “People just can’t find anything.”

For buyers and sellers alike, waiting for perfect conditions is unlikely to pay off. In a market this tight, the best strategy is to act decisively when the right opportunity appears.

About the Expert: Jack Bohman is the lead agent and co-founder of The Bohman Hartung Group at Gibson Sotheby’s International Realty in Chatham, Massachusetts. His team was the top producer for Gibson Sotheby’s in 2025, specializing in Cape Cod’s luxury and coastal markets.

This article is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or investment advice. The views and opinions expressed herein reflect those of the individuals quoted and do not represent an endorsement of any company, product, or service mentioned. Readers should conduct their own due diligence and consult qualified professionals before making any investment decisions.