Two years ago, Manhattan’s office market carried vacancy rates around 25 percent, a figure that reflected years of pandemic-era uncertainty and leasing volume that had cratered from a ...
In Chicago's Western Suburbs, Underpricing Stale Listings Is Generating Bidding Wars
Written by:
Date:
01 Sep 2026
Share via Facebook
Share via Linkedin
Share via X
Copy to clipboard
A property that sits on the market too long in the Chicago suburbs doesn’t just lose momentum; it loses credibility with buyers. Listings that expire without a sale carry a stigma, and relisting at the same or higher price rarely solves the underlying problem. But agents working the Berwyn corridor and surrounding towns are finding that aggressive underpricing on expired listings can reverse the dynamic entirely, turning dead inventory into competitive bidding situations.
Javier Alday, a Realtor with Realty of America who leads an 11-agent team in the Berwyn area, describes a recent deal that illustrates the approach. A seller had listed a rehabbed property with another agent at $380,000. It didn’t sell. After the listing expired, Alday’s team cold-called the seller and proposed a different strategy: list at $300,000, well below the seller’s $350,000 target – to generate immediate demand.
“We priced it at 300. So that generated a lot of traction in the process. And then we got multiple offers,” Alday says. “We go back to the buyer’s agents, and we call for highest and best.” The property closed at $345,000 – $5,000 below the seller’s original goal, but a far better outcome than months of inactivity at $380,000.
For sellers stuck with expired listings, the lesson is counterintuitive: the price that attracts no buyers at all may be closer to market value than the price that attracts many. Listing below target created the competition that brought the final sale price back up to within reach of the seller’s goal.
Where the Buyers Are Coming From
The composition of buyers in Chicago’s western suburbs splits along a predictable line: property condition. Homes needing substantial work draw investors – either fix-and-flip operators or buyers building rental portfolios. Properties requiring lighter renovation attract first-time homebuyers, often using down payment assistance programs and negotiating seller-paid closing costs.
For investors, the calculation hasn’t changed. Alday says they make their money on the purchase, not the sale. The process is straightforward: estimate renovation costs with a contractor, compare to recent comparable sales in the area, and determine whether the spread justifies the purchase. “As long as the numbers make sense, then it’s a good buy,” he says.
The south side of Chicago is where Alday sees the most active investor interest right now. Buyers are acquiring properties at low prices, completing renovations, and selling at returns that justify the risk. “We see a lot of people going in, getting properties for a really good price, and after they flip them, they make a substantial amount of return,” he says.
Seasonal Patterns Shape Listing Strategy
Chicago’s residential market follows a pronounced seasonal curve that shapes both listing strategy and buyer urgency. Activity peaks in spring – driven by families aligning moves with school schedules, and declines steadily through summer into the holiday months.
Alday explains that by August, families who needed to move before the school year have already closed. “People that had to renew leases or buy a new house, they have already bought three, four months ago,” he says. He compares the annual pattern to a stock chart: high at the beginning of the year, trickling down through fall and winter.
Transactions don’t stop during the slower months. “People buy homes every day. There are closings at title companies every single day,” Alday notes. But volume drops, and agents without active prospecting pipelines feel it most. For sellers, this means listing in the spring window captures the largest buyer pool, while listings that hit the market in late summer or fall face thinner demand – making pricing strategy even more critical during those months.
Neighborhoods Outperforming
Within the broader Chicagoland market, several areas are consistently outperforming. Lincoln Park remains strong, and Oak Park and Brookfield, both close to Berwyn, are seeing properties sell quickly once listed. “Every time something goes on the market, it flies out of the door,” Alday says of those two towns.
On the speculative side, he offers a cautionary note. News about the Chicago Bears potentially relocating, first to Arlington Heights, now closer to Indiana, has historically moved buyer behavior in ways that don’t pay off. “A few years ago, the Chicago Bears said they were going to move into Arlington Heights. Many people bought in Arlington Heights thinking that was going to happen, but that didn’t end up happening,” Alday says.
His advice to buyers considering speculation on stadium-adjacent real estate: “Even though the news headlines do move people, the decisions on what they’re going to do are far from happening. I’d be careful with that.” Buyers who purchased in Arlington Heights based on that earlier announcement absorbed risk on a development that never materialized.
A Structural Gap in Housing Supply
Beyond seasonal cycles and neighborhood dynamics, Alday points to what he sees as a shortage in the Chicago market: affordable multi-family housing for lower-income residents. “We don’t have enough of that. That’s why rents are super high in Chicago,” he says. He’d like to see more investment from large-scale developers or government in building condos or apartment buildings for lower-income families, describing it as something “the Chicagoland area is in need” of.
That shortage has a direct effect on the broader market. High rents push more residents toward homeownership, but without enough affordable inventory to absorb that demand, competition intensifies at the lower end of the price spectrum, the same segment where Alday’s team is most active with its underpricing strategy.
What Chicago’s Market Offers Investors
Alday attributes part of Chicago’s appeal to the employment base. Manufacturing, production, and large corporate employers provide the income foundation that keeps housing demand steady. “There are a lot of factories, a lot of production, a lot of big companies that are in Chicago. So that helps people be able to transition into new properties,” he says.
The tradeoff is weather. Alday says bluntly that if Chicago had California’s climate, Illinois would be overpopulated. The harsh winters keep population growth in check, which in turn keeps prices from reaching coastal levels, creating a spread between acquisition cost and post-renovation value that investors in warmer markets can’t easily find.
For investors evaluating the Chicago market from out of state, the combination matters: strong employment supporting rental demand, acquisition prices low enough to leave room for renovation profit, and seasonal patterns that create predictable windows of opportunity for both buying and selling.
About the Expert: Javier Alday is a Realtor with Realty of America, leading an 11-agent team in the Berwyn, Illinois area.
This article is based on information provided by the expert source cited above. It is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or real estate advice. Readers should conduct their own research and consult qualified professionals before making any real estate or financial decisions.
Similar Articles
Explore similar articles from Our Team of Experts.
