The Property Management Growth Paradox: Why Most Real Estate Investors Are Choosing the Wrong Partners

Written by:

Steve Marcinuk

Date:

27 Jun 2025

Share

Share via Facebook

Share via Linkedin

Share via X

Copy to clipboard

The property management industry faces a disconnect that’s costing real estate investors millions in lost opportunities. While investors often approach real estate agents first when seeking new properties, industry veterans suggest this path may be backwards and expensive.

Jason Hull, CEO of DoorGrow and host of the Property Management Growth with DoorGrow podcast, has spent over a decade coaching property management companies and has identified patterns that reveal why most real estate investors are making critical partnership mistakes. Hull’s perspective, shaped by working with hundreds of property management business owners, offers insights into an industry where the right partnerships can make or break investment success.

The Backwards Approach to Real Estate Investment

“One of the biggest mistakes real estate investors make is not using a property manager,” Hull explains. “But if they can find a good property manager—and most are not effective—then that’s their most critical partner.”

Most investors start by contacting real estate agents, whose primary incentive is securing commissions rather than optimizing investment returns. “Real estate agents’ goal is to just line their pocket with a commission,” Hull notes. “But property managers will tell you where the best areas are, whether a property would cash flow effectively, whether it could be a good investment or a good rental.”

Hull’s experience in the industry began with building websites for property management companies and has since evolved into rebranding over 320 companies and coaching hundreds of business owners. The relationship-first approach Hull advocates represents a shift in investment strategy: treating property managers as strategic partners, not just service providers hired after acquisition.

Debunking the Growth Myths

Hull has identified two persistent myths in the property management industry, misconceptions that ultimately impact investor outcomes.

The first is “the leads myth.” Property managers believe they need more leads to grow, but Hull says the real issue is elsewhere. “What we’ve found is they don’t actually need more leads. They need less leaks,” Hull explains. “They usually have a lot of leaks in their process, leaks of trust, leaks in their pipeline.”

Operational deficiencies, such as unanswered phones, poor pricing strategies, weak branding, and inadequate sales processes, are often the culprits. Addressing these issues can double a company’s deal flow without changing their lead generation efforts.

The second misconception is “the process myth” affecting companies in the 200-400 door range. At this stage, property managers think better processes and metrics will solve their scaling challenges. “The myth is, if I could micromanage my team well enough, I could squeeze more blood from a stone,” Hull says.

However, Hull’s experience shows: “There’s no amount of processes that will make mediocre team members perform great. But I’ve seen companies with terrible processes and amazing people who figure out how to create good systems because the people are good, intelligent, and care.”

This insight has important implications for investors evaluating property management partners. Companies focused solely on process optimization may miss the fundamental element that drives success: quality people and culture.

Technology’s Role in a Relationship Business

As artificial intelligence and automation impact industries, property management faces unique challenges in balancing technological efficiency with human connection. Hull acknowledges the AI revolution while emphasizing property management’s inherently relationship-driven nature.

“People have come in and tried to systematize or tech out property management, and they’ve failed and gone under,” Hull observes. “It’s a relationship business.”

He draws an analogy to personal relationships: if someone used ChatGPT to respond to their spouse during a conflict, the artificial nature of that response would undermine rather than strengthen the relationship. “There’s this human aspect that I think will become a premium. Real human interactions will be valued even more.”

This suggests that while technology will play a role in efficiency, the most successful property management companies will be those that maintain strong human connections with both investors and tenants.

The True Product Property Managers Sell

Hull’s analysis reveals a critical misunderstanding about what property managers offer investors. “Nobody wants to buy property management,” he explains. “Property management is just a vehicle to help investors get what they want. It’s like the flight to Hawaii, they’re not super excited about the flight.”

Most property managers mistakenly sell the service rather than the outcome. The actual product, according to Hull, is trust, specifically, in the business owner, their culture, team, and overall system. “They want to buy trust in that. And that’s different in every company, whereas property management is pretty much the same in every company.”

This explains why treating property management as a commodity leads to poor outcomes. Investors who simply choose the cheapest option often end up with inadequate service, while those who invest in trusted partnerships receive value that extends far beyond basic property management.

The best property managers function as investment advisors, helping clients evaluate potential acquisitions, optimize cash flow, explore refinancing options, and identify new opportunities. “They’re helping you with creative financing structuring. They’re people you can lean on to help you make better decisions, because they are the experts with real estate investing.”

Market Opportunities in Mid-2025

Hull’s current observations reveal emerging opportunities in the real estate market. “The real estate market is softening right now,” he reports. “There’s a lot of properties that have been sitting on the market for too long, and people are starting to get uncomfortable and fold.”

This is particularly pronounced in the multifamily space, where duplexes and larger properties face extended market times. “If you’ve been stacking cash as a real estate investor, there’s some opportunities coming out of the market right now,” Hull notes. “People have properties that have been sitting there for four months, maybe half a year, and they’re ready to move them because they’re hemorrhaging money.”

For investors who have maintained liquidity, these conditions present acquisition opportunities, especially when working with property managers who can quickly assess whether distressed properties represent genuine value.

The Hidden Advantage of Property Manager Partnerships

Beyond operational expertise, property managers offer access to opportunities that rarely reach the open market. “Property managers get the best deals,” Hull reveals. “They know of the best off-market deals. If you’re friends with good property managers, they have investors that are selling stuff all the time.”

These relationships provide access to seller financing and creative deal structures not available through traditional channels. Property managers often know when owners need to exit properties quickly, creating opportunities for investors with established partnerships.

“The smart property managers are eating up those deals for themselves, and if they don’t want it or can’t do it, then maybe they’d give it to you,” Hull explains. “That’s better than just finding what’s on the market that a real estate agent can have, which are the scraps that fall off the property management table.”

Building the Right Partnership Strategy

For investors seeking to optimize property management relationships, Hull recommends a shift in approach. Instead of viewing property managers as service providers hired after acquisition, successful investors treat them as strategic partners consulted before making investment decisions.

This requires moving beyond commodity-based selection criteria and finding property managers who demonstrate expertise, maintain strong team cultures, and provide strategic guidance beyond basic management services.

The most effective property managers help investors avoid common pitfalls while identifying opportunities that align with their goals. They provide market intelligence, expertise, and access to off-market deals that can significantly impact long-term returns.

As the real estate market evolves, these partnerships become increasingly valuable. Property managers who have navigated previous market cycles offer insights that help investors make better decisions during uncertainty.

For real estate investors looking to optimize portfolio performance, the message is clear: the right property management partnership isn’t just about operational efficiency, it’s about gaining access to expertise, opportunities, and market intelligence that can improve investment outcomes. The question isn’t whether to use a property manager, but rather how to find one worthy of a true strategic partnership.