For many buyers, Staten Island occupies an unusual place in the New York City housing market. It is fully part of NYC, with the same municipal services, tax structure, and transit connections. Yet its housing stock and pricing often look very different from what buyers encounter in Manhattan, Brooklyn, or Queens. Single-family homes are far more common, space is generally less constrained, and the pace of the market tends to be less intense.
These differences can create confusion, especially for buyers who assume the same conditions apply across all five boroughs. Some expect constant bidding wars, while others believe they need perfect credit or must wait for a major price drop before entering the market. In reality, Staten Island operates on its own set of dynamics, shaped by its housing mix, buyer pool, and local demand.
Kevin Borgersen, broker associate with Red Door Realty Group, has spent over a decade guiding buyers through the Staten Island market. He regularly encounters the same misconceptions — and sees how they can delay or complicate decisions. Understanding how the borough’s market actually works can help buyers focus on what matters and make more informed choices.
Misconception: Staten Island home prices behave like those in other New York City boroughs
Reality: Staten Island’s housing market tends to follow its own trajectory. The other NYC markets are more heavily influenced by investor activity, large-scale development, and rapid shifts in demand, which can lead to sharper price swings. Staten Island, by contrast, is defined primarily by owner-occupied single-family homes and smaller residential communities, with fewer large speculative projects.
This housing mix contributes to more gradual price movement. Even as activity has slowed across the broader New York City market, Staten Island home prices have remained relatively stable, rising modestly over the past year rather than experiencing dramatic fluctuations. Borgersen says buyers who delay purchases in anticipation of a steep decline may find that prices continue to move incrementally instead of dropping significantly. The Staten Island market tends to reflect local demand rather than the volatility seen elsewhere in the city.
Misconception: You’ll have heavy competition from bcash buyers and investors
Reality: In higher-density boroughs such as Manhattan and parts of Brooklyn, investors often compete directly with primary residence buyers for the same apartments, frequently beating them out on prime properties. Staten Island’s housing market is structured differently. Much of the inventory consists of single-family homes purchased by owner-occupants, and many condos and smaller houses attract buyers intending to live in the property rather than rent it out. Investor activity in Staten Island is more concentrated in specific property types, particularly multifamily homes that can generate rental income.
Borgersen says this distinction shapes how competition plays out. “First-time home buyers are not competing with investors,” he explains, noting that investors tend to focus on properties with clear income potential. As a result, buyers searching for condos or modest single-family homes are often competing primarily with other households, not institutional investors or cash-heavy buyers. The dynamics reflect Staten Island’s role as a residential borough, where demand is driven more by local housing needs than by large-scale investment activity.
Misconception: Staten Island offers a suburban lifestyle separate from the realities of New York City
Reality: While Staten Island has more single-family homes and lower population density than other boroughs, it remains part of New York City in every meaningful sense. Residents live under the same municipal government, public safety systems, and urban infrastructure as the rest of the city. Citywide issues — such as crime, traffic congestion, aging infrastructure, and environmental concerns — exist here as well, even if their scale or visibility varies from neighborhood to neighborhood. For buyers considering Staten Island, the distinction is not between city living and suburban living, but between different forms of city living.
The borough’s housing stock may offer more space and a quieter residential setting in many areas, but it is not insulated from broader urban conditions. Public schools, transit service, sanitation, zoning, and emergency services all operate within the same city framework. Borgersen says buyers are often drawn by the additional space available, but they are still choosing to live within New York City. “We just have a lot more elbow room,” he explains.
Misconception: Buyers can expect to get a bargain in Staten Island
Reality: While Staten Island may offer more space and lower price points than some other boroughs, sellers respond to the same supply and demand dynamics that shape the rest of the city’s housing market. Homes that are well-priced and in good condition often attract strong interest, particularly in neighborhoods with limited inventory. In these cases, sellers may receive multiple offers or hold firm on their asking price.
Borgersen says the outcome of negotiations depends less on the borough and more on how the property is positioned in the market. You’ll still run into serious buyers competing for desirable homes. Properties that require updates or have been on the market longer may offer more room for negotiation, but buyers should not assume that sellers are under pressure to accept reduced offers.
Misconception: Buying a Staten Island home requires perfect credit because it’s still New York City
Reality: Buyers do not need perfect credit to qualify for a mortgage on Staten Island — or anywhere else in New York City, for that matter. Lenders evaluate a range of factors, including credit history, income stability, debt levels, and the overall affordability of the loan, rather than requiring flawless credit scores.
At the same time, the borough’s lower average home prices compared to Manhattan and parts of Brooklyn can make qualifying more attainable for some buyers. Because loan amounts are often smaller, the financial thresholds for approval may be easier to meet even under the same underwriting standards.
Borgersen says many buyers assume they need flawless credit to enter the market, but lenders evaluate the full financial picture. “You don’t need perfect credit,” he explains, “just stable income and a realistic budget.” As elsewhere in New York City, qualification ultimately depends on how a buyer’s financial profile aligns with the price of the home, rather than the borough in which the property is located.
Misconception: Staten Island buyers should wait for interest rates to drop
Reality: Interest rates are only one part of the affordability equation. Borgersen says buyers sometimes delay their search in anticipation of lower rates, but overall affordability depends on the relationship between borrowing costs, home prices, and individual financial circumstances. Changes in one factor do not always offset changes in another.
On Staten Island, shifts in interest rates can also influence how many buyers are active in the market at a given time. When rates rise, some buyers step back, which can slow competition and give remaining buyers more time to evaluate properties. When rates fall, more buyers often reenter the market, increasing demand for the same homes. As a result, the conditions buyers encounter — such as how quickly homes sell or how much competition they face — can change even if the homes themselves remain similar.
The Bottom Line
Staten Island occupies a distinct place within New York City’s housing landscape. It offers a different mix of homes, pricing, and neighborhood character than higher-density boroughs, but it remains shaped by the same financial systems, lending standards, and economic forces. Buyers who approach the market with assumptions drawn either from Manhattan’s intensity or from fully suburban environments may overlook how Staten Island actually functions.
As borrowing costs, inventory levels, and buyer demand continue to evolve, the Staten Island market is likely to reflect the same broader trends affecting the rest of the city — though often in ways shaped by its more residential housing stock. Understanding those dynamics can help buyers evaluate opportunities more clearly and make decisions based on their own financial position and long-term priorities.
About Kevin Borgersen: Kevin Borgersen is a broker associate and company trainer at Red Door Realty Group in Staten Island, New York. He specializes in residential real estate, working with first-time buyers, retirees, and families relocating within the metro area. He was recently elected to the Staten Island Board of Realtors as a director.
This article is based on information and perspectives provided by a local real estate professional familiar with the Staten Island housing market. It is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or investment advice. Readers should conduct their own research and consult qualified professionals before making any real estate or financial decisions.
This article was sourced from a live expert interview.
Every month we conduct hundreds of interviews with active market practitioners - thousands to date.
High mortgage rates and persistent home prices are forcing buyers in Northern Virginia to reconsider where they can afford to live, according to Desiree Rejeili, Principal/Owner of Desiree S...
After months of rapid sales and intense competition, Memphis homebuyers are finally seeing the market move in their favor. Properties are staying on the market longer, sellers are offering n...
As Phoenix’s housing market grows more competitive, locals are paying close attention to a handful of neighborhoods where new investment, infrastructure, and job growth are quietly taking ...
In most parts of the country, a $5 million home would dominate the luxury market. In Silicon Valley, it can feel almost ordinary. In this elite pocket of California, properties priced betwee...
The signs are everywhere: “We Buy Houses – Cash – Fast.” If you’ve ever wondered whether these offers are legitimate or simply a way to undercut sellers, you’re not alone...
Farmington Hills has overhauled its zoning code, updated its master plan, and begun actively courting new development over the past several years. The changes respond to post-pandemic shifts...
