Why Selling Inherited Real Estate Is Harder Than Most Heirs Expect

Written by:

Steve Marcinuk

Date:

07 May 2026

Share

Share via Facebook

Share via Linkedin

Share via X

Copy to clipboard

The great wealth transfer has been discussed in financial circles for years. Still, the practical reality of what happens when families actually inherit real estate is far messier than the headline numbers suggest. Probate timelines, multi-heir disagreements, stepped-up basis decisions, and the challenge of finding the right broker for an unfamiliar property type – these are the friction points that determine whether an inherited property sale closes smoothly or drags on for years.

Rhett Fruitman, Co-Founder of Inherited Property Match, has built a business around that friction. His platform operates as a free broker matching service, not a brokerage, connecting heirs, executors, trustees, personal representatives, and fiduciaries with brokers suited to their specific property type, location, legal status, and family circumstances.

A Different Kind of Real Estate Service

Most people selling inherited real estate don’t have the tools to identify whether a broker is competent, let alone whether they’re the right fit for a specific asset. A residential agent who handles $600,000 houses isn’t equipped to sell a $6 million property, and when the property is out of state, heirs have even less ability to vet who they’re working with.

Fruitman’s background spans institutional finance and commercial real estate – from interning at CBRE’s Denver capital markets division to Citi Private Bank in Los Angeles. That experience shaped his approach to broker evaluation. “My expertise is in judging people and judging the track record and doing due diligence on them,” he says. “That takes up the vast majority of my day.”

The service operates across all 50 states, requiring familiarity with single-family homes, condos and townhomes, vacation homes, land, multifamily properties, commercial real estate, investment properties, triple-net properties, local market dynamics, and broker specializations. A recent example involved a restaurant chain’s triple-net property in Ohio, a 30-year lease with roughly a decade remaining. Rather than defaulting to whoever ranked highest in a Google search, Fruitman’s team identified a broker with specific expertise in that restaurant chain’s property type. “Different types of retail have different broker specialties,” he explains. “Some brokers really focus on restaurants, some focus on banks.”

There’s also a built-in accountability mechanism. Because brokers in the network want continued referrals, they have a direct incentive to perform well. Fruitman notes that brokers who know a client won’t return for future business may not deliver their best work. “Because these brokers hope to work with us in the future, they’re happy to go above and beyond,” he says.

What Makes Selling Inherited Property So Complex?

One of the more consistent patterns Fruitman sees is how unprepared heirs are for the process, not because they’re unsophisticated, but because inherited property sales involve legal, financial, and interpersonal layers that standard residential transactions don’t. Before a sale can move forward, families often need to determine who has legal authority to act – whether that is an executor, personal representative, trustee, or, in some cases, an heir who has received title.

The professional ecosystem alone is substantial. Probate attorneys handle local paperwork, with ancillary probate required when property is out of state. CPAs navigate the tax picture. Estate planning attorneys, if the decedent had one, may have established living trusts that simplify the process considerably. And the broker’s role extends well beyond listing the property, often including advising on whether to make repairs, whether to continue renting, or explaining what’s legally permissible at a given stage of probate.

“No two heirs are alike,” Fruitman says. “The core job is understanding exactly what the client needs, and then finding the right broker that fits exactly their need.”

One financial concept that frequently catches heirs off guard, in a positive way, is the stepped-up basis. Under current tax law, heirs can inherit and sell appreciated assets with the cost basis reset to fair market value at the time of death, making date-of-death valuation and appraisal documentation important when determining potential capital gains exposure. Some heirs discover they can sell a property worth a million dollars with little or no tax owed because of this reset. Fruitman is quick to add that the specifics always require a CPA and attorney to clarify, particularly when an estate is divided among multiple heirs.

Why Do Multi-Heir Inherited Property Sales Get Delayed?

Perhaps the most avoidable source of deal failure in inherited property sales is anchoring bias – when heirs develop a fixed idea of what a property is worth, often based on Zillow estimates or an early broker opinion that was inflated to win the listing.

Fruitman describes a common scenario: heirs who are told their house is worth a million dollars refuse to accept an $850,000 market reality. “A lot of times, people hold out for years trying to get the better offer,” he says. What they often underestimate is the carrying cost of that delay, debt service, HOA fees, property taxes, and maintenance all continue accruing while the property sits.

The problem compounds when multiple heirs are involved. A single holdout who believes the property is undervalued can stall a sale indefinitely. Fruitman estimates that co-heir disagreements blow up a sale less than 10% of the time, noting that as stress accumulates, most parties eventually align around accepting a fair market offer. But the path there can be long.

Harder-to-Value Assets Create More Friction

While most inherited homes can be priced using comparable sales, some asset types resist straightforward valuation. Fruitman points to land as a particularly complex example – one his team is currently working through. Land may attract homebuilders, or it may contain natural resources like oil or rare earths, and because those markets aren’t liquid, pulling reliable comps is difficult.

The same logic applies to any asset that’s one-off in nature. Office buildings carry a different kind of uncertainty right now, given ongoing questions around remote work. Meanwhile, land in certain Texas markets has taken on new relevance as data center operators seek cheap energy access.

Macro Factors in the 2026 Market

These individual property challenges are playing out against a shifting economic backdrop. Fruitman is watching several macro variables that could meaningfully affect the inherited property market over the next 12 to 18 months. Interest rate expectations are moving with anticipated leadership changes at the Federal Reserve. Ongoing geopolitical tensions, including conflicts affecting oil supply and the continued closure of key shipping routes, introduce inflation risk that could keep rates elevated longer than buyers hope. And the AI cycle is creating divergent outcomes across asset classes, with land and data-adjacent properties potentially benefiting while office assets face continued pressure.

Heirs who are already navigating an unfamiliar process are more prone to mistimed decisions as macro conditions shift. “Real estate is a very dynamic world, and a lot can change very quickly,” Fruitman says.

Building for the Long Term

Inherited Property Match is growing its team and expanding its broker network heading into the second half of 2026. The referral-driven nature of the business means that reputation is the primary asset; a bad broker match reflects directly on the platform, which keeps the vetting process central to everything Fruitman does.

For families navigating the sale of inherited real estate, the takeaway is consistent: the complexity is real, the stakes are high, and the difference between a decent broker and a great one is larger than most people realize going in. Those who move early to assemble the right professional team, an attorney, a CPA, and a broker matched to the specific property, tend to avoid the delays and losses that catch less-prepared heirs off guard.

About the Expert: Rhett Fruitman is the Co-Founder of Inherited Property Match, a broker matching service that connects heirs, executors, and fiduciaries with specialists suited to their specific property type, location, and situation.

This article is based on information provided by the expert source cited above. It is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or real estate advice. Readers should conduct their own research and consult qualified professionals before making any real estate or financial decisions.