Home Buyers in Virginia’s Hampton Roads Face Monthly Payment Increases

Written by:

Rudi Davis

Date:

02 Mar 2026

Share

Share via Facebook

Share via Linkedin

Share via X

Copy to clipboard

While mortgage rates remain the focus of most real estate coverage, a separate affordability crisis is emerging in Hampton Roads as insurance premiums and property taxes climb sharply. These increases are raising monthly housing costs by 11-12% — even before factoring in interest rates — creating a structural affordability problem that lower rates alone cannot fix, according to Dan Patton, a realtor with Prodigy Realty LLC.

Insurance Premiums Surge

In the past year, insurance costs have jumped significantly in Hampton Roads, with many buyers caught off guard by increases that add hundreds of dollars to their monthly payments. Patton explains that the problem is not limited to local conditions: “Insurance has gone up drastically in our market, but nationwide, there’s been a lot of insurance companies that have closed up shop and have pulled out of our area.” Companies are leaving coastal and climate-exposed regions due to rising flood risks and catastrophic losses. As a result, the remaining insurance providers have gained pricing power, forcing buyers to accept higher premiums or risk losing coverage options altogether.

Many buyers enter the purchase process using outdated insurance estimates, only to discover late in the transaction that their actual premiums will be much higher. This pushes total monthly costs above what lenders originally calculated, and in some cases, above what buyers can afford. The impact is especially severe for buyers who are already close to their debt-to-income limits.

Property Tax Reassessments

At the same time, property tax bills have risen due to pandemic-era home price appreciation. Local governments have reassessed values upward, leading to higher annual tax obligations. Patton notes, “Taxes have gone up because the homes now are worth more post-COVID, so everything is kind of hitting the buyer’s pocket.” The combined effect of higher insurance and property taxes means that even buyers who qualify for a mortgage at today’s rates may find their total monthly housing costs unaffordable.

Most affordability analyses focus on mortgage rates and home prices, but in Hampton Roads, insurance and tax increases are just as significant — and often overlooked — drivers of what buyers can actually afford.

Affordability Gap

The rapid depletion of local grant programs is another sign of market stress. Patton points to a recent “heroes” grant program that offered $10,000 in assistance. “It was supposed to run out in June or July or August, and it ran out in mid-February,” he says. The program was depleted 4 to 6 months earlier, showing that demand for financial help far outpaces available resources. To stretch funds further, administrators are now considering cutting the grant amount in half, effectively rationing support rather than increasing it.

Patton observes, “Everybody is really interested in buying a creative way to either buy down that rate or get their closing costs covered — just help out. Because, again, the monthly payments are still pretty high right now.” The heavy reliance on grants and concessions signals that the affordability gap is wider than many in the industry acknowledge. If buyers in a region with stable employment and strong military demand need $10,000 in aid to close, the underlying cost pressures are severe.

Mortgage Rate Drops

The focus on mortgage rates as the main affordability lever may not reflect the new reality. While sellers in Hampton Roads benefit from locked-in 2-4% rates, new buyers face rates of 6-7%, plus the added burden of higher insurance and taxes. Patton notes that even if rates fell to 5%, total monthly payments would still be much higher than before the pandemic due to these other rising costs.

This dynamic has slowed the market, trapping move-up buyers who do not want to give up low-rate mortgages and leaving most transactions to first-time buyers and relocating military personnel. With monthly payments remaining high despite the prospect of lower rates, the traditional relationship between mortgage rates and housing affordability appears to be breaking down — especially in coastal and climate-exposed markets.

Looking Ahead

The Hampton Roads market now faces a structural challenge: housing affordability is being driven less by mortgage rates and more by fixed costs like insurance and taxes. These increases are unlikely to reverse, meaning buyers and sellers alike must adjust their expectations. As Patton’s experience shows, the industry can no longer assume that a rate drop alone will bring relief. In the future, the true test for Hampton Roads and similar markets will be whether incomes and policy interventions can keep pace with rising non-mortgage costs — or whether the affordability gap will continue to widen.