Acreage Properties and New Construction Emerge as Top Performers in Sarasota Real Estate

Written by:

Steve Marcinuk

Date:

03 Nov 2025

Share

Share via Facebook

Share via Linkedin

Share via X

Copy to clipboard

While much of Sarasota’s real estate market faces price corrections and inventory constraints, two property segments are outperforming the rest, according to Joey Lamielle, team leader at RE/MAX Alliance Group. Acreage properties and new construction communities are attracting the most buyer interest in the current market.

Market Segmentation Analysis

“Acreage properties are thriving right now. Properties with a little more space,” said Lamielle, who has 12 years of experience in the Sarasota market. This trend reflects a shift in buyer priorities as the market matures and long-term residents seek different living arrangements.

The new construction segment is also robust but driven by separate motivations. “There’s a lot of new builds coming in. Builders are making it to the point where you’re very incentivized to buy with closing costs, and they’re knocking, slashing prices down, and giving more upgrades.”

Acreage Demand Drivers

Lamielle notes that the acreage market appeals to established Sarasota residents undergoing lifestyle changes.

“There’s another segment of our market that’s been here for a while and starting to see Sarasota really blossom. And they’re like, Okay, this is great. I still want to call this home, but I need a little more breathing room.”

The appeal centers on privacy and avoiding high-density development, where “you can reach out the door of our living room and borrow an egg from the neighbor.”

However, Lamielle points out that zoning restrictions limit further development of these properties. “There’s not a lot of properties that you can say, hey, great. You know, I have 10 acre property. Let’s go ahead and subdivide into two or three or four parcels and be able to build like you really just can’t do that. Our zoning is not set up for it.”

New Construction Advantages

The new construction market is thriving on buyer convenience and builder incentives rather than location premiums. Lamielle highlights the appeal: “It’s very attractive for newer buyers and people that don’t want to do any renovations at all, going into a new build community, everything’s brand new.”

Builders are offering significant incentives, making new homes competitive with existing inventory that may require updates or repairs.

Market Contrast with Struggling Segments

These successful segments contrast sharply with others facing challenges. The luxury market above $2 million remains active due to cash buyers moving capital from strong stock market gains, while the middle market ($400,000–$500,000) faces affordability issues as monthly payments have increased from “$2,800 a month” three years ago to “$4,000 a month” today.

The condo market has been especially impacted, with 20–25% value declines tied to insurance challenges and post-Surfside regulations.

Investment Strategy Implications

The divergence between property types highlights increasing market sophistication as buyers focus more on location, condition, and long-term value. Cash buyers, who make up 68.5% of townhouse and condo purchases, are particularly drawn to these thriving segments for their clear value and lower complexity.

Lamielle’s insights suggest that navigating today’s market requires understanding these micro-market dynamics rather than relying on generalized assumptions across property types and price ranges.