Let Us Help: 1 (855) CREW-123
Get Published

Verified Property Management Professionals in New Castle, Indiana, 2026

This directory includes Property Management professionals operating in New Castle, Indiana. Profiles may be verified by KeyCrew or currently under review as part of our ongoing verification process. If you’re a local expert and aren’t listed here, book your verification call. Get Verified

Refine Your Search

Use the filters below to narrow down your options.

Realty Wealth Advisors-Logo
View Profile

Realty Wealth Advisors

This business has not yet been verified. Verified status is granted after a short phone interview confirming credentials and professional background.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Muncie, IN | New Castle, IN | Elwood, IN | Fishers, IN + 4 Others
Agent, Team & Broker
Property Management

Realty Wealth Advisors is a real estate investment company that specializes in acquiring and managing residential and multi-family properties across Indiana. With over 25 years of experience, they offer a range of services including property management and investment opportunities to help clients achieve financial freedom through real estate investing.

Property Types:
  • Multifamily
  • Residential

Overall reviews say that Realty Wealth Advisors, particularly their leasing agent Mike Hasell, have provided excellent service to clients looking to rent homes. Clients praise Mike's responsiveness, professionalism, and ability to quickly get them approved and moved into their desired homes, even in challenging situations. The maintenance team is also highlighted for their prompt and helpful service.

Golden Sky Management-Logo
View Profile

Golden Sky Management

This business has not yet been verified. Verified status is granted after a short phone interview confirming credentials and professional background.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Anderson, IN | Indianapolis, IN | Muncie, IN | New Castle, IN
Property Management

Golden Sky Management is a premier property management company in Indiana, offering full-service management for residential, multi-family, commercial, and HOA properties. They utilize cutting-edge technology to provide exceptional, hands-on management, consistently exceeding market averages for occupancy rates and tenant satisfaction.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • HOA/COA
  • Multifamily
  • Commercial

"Overall, reviews indicate that real estate professionals and clients are highly satisfied with Golden Sky Management's services. The company is praised for its responsive and friendly staff, well-maintained properties, and ability to address tenant needs in a timely manner. Reviewers highlight the company's professionalism, cleanliness of apartments, and overall positive rental experience."

PMI Indianapolis-Logo
View Profile

PMI Indianapolis

This business has not yet been verified. Verified status is granted after a short phone interview confirming credentials and professional background.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Anderson, IN | Carmel, IN | Greenfield, IN | Greenwood, IN + 8 Others
Property Management

PMI Indianapolis is a full-service real estate asset management company that provides professional Residential, Commercial, Short-Term, and Realty services across the Indianapolis metropolitan area. They utilize state-of-the-art technology to help property owners manage their investments and provide tenants with real-time access to maintenance requests and billing.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multifamily
  • Commercial
  • Mixed-Use

"Overall reviews say that PMI Indianapolis has been helpful and responsive in assisting clients with their real estate needs. Clients have praised the company's maintenance team for their prompt and efficient service, as well as specific team members like John Perez, Kate, and Albert for their excellent customer service and problem-solving abilities."

MiddleTown Living-Logo
View Profile

MiddleTown Living

This business has not yet been verified. Verified status is granted after a short phone interview confirming credentials and professional background.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Anderson, IN | Crawfordsville, IN | Indianapolis, IN | Kokomo, IN + 10 Others
Property Management

MiddleTown Living is a third-party property management company that provides affordable rental properties with great locations across Central, East Central, and Northeast Indiana, catering to the residential, affordable housing, and student housing sectors.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Affordable Housing
  • Student Housing
  • Multifamily

"Reviews say MiddleTown Living has a dedicated property manager, Elizabeth Russel, who provides excellent service and goes above and beyond to accommodate clients' needs. However, the company has also received negative feedback regarding issues with maintenance, cleanliness, and overall property conditions, including problems with water, mold, pests, and appliances not functioning properly."

Samco Properties Inc-Logo
View Profile

Samco Properties Inc

This business has not yet been verified. Verified status is granted after a short phone interview confirming credentials and professional background.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Willimantic, CT | Deerfield Beach, FL | Ocala, FL | Elberton, GA + 51 Others
Property Management

Samco Properties is a privately held commercial real estate company that specializes in the ownership, operation, acquisition, and improvement of neighborhood and community shopping centers, office buildings, and single-tenant commercial properties across the southeastern United States.

Property Types:
  • Commercial
  • Mixed-Use

Generally, clients of Samco Properties Inc. express positive sentiments about the company's efforts to revitalize and maintain their commercial properties. Reviewers highlight the company's vision, service quality, and responsiveness in managing their properties, with one client specifically praising the Heritage Place/Moline office building as being among the finest in the Quad Cities area.

Father & Son Property Maintenance & Management-Logo
View Profile

Father & Son Property Maintenance & Management

This business has not yet been verified. Verified status is granted after a short phone interview confirming credentials and professional background.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Anderson, IN | Connersville, IN | Crawfordsville, IN | Kokomo, IN + 11 Others
Property Management

Father & Son Property Maintenance is a residential contractor serving the Anderson, Indiana area. As a family-run business, they provide reliable property maintenance and repair services for homeowners with a focus on quality workmanship and customer satisfaction.

Property Types:
  • Residential

"Generally, reviews indicate that clients are satisfied with the company's prompt, professional, and reliable service. The company has been praised for its quick response to emergencies, fair pricing, and high-quality workmanship. Clients highlight the company's willingness to work with them, especially those on limited incomes, and the overall positive attitude of the staff."

About the KeyCrew Expert Network

Learn how experts are added, reviewed, and organized

Verification & Review Process

Understand how KeyCrew evaluates and updates profiles

Expert Insights & Market Analysis

In-depth research and expert perspectives from KeyCrew's research team and network of industry leaders, helping you make smarter real estate decisions.

More Articles

Keep Up-To-Date With The Latest KeyCrew Updates

We’re constantly releasing new features and adding new providers to our real estate industry database. Sign up to our mailing list to be kept up-to-date as we roll out upcoming features.