Let Us Help: 1 (855) CREW-123

Best Property Manager Companies in Lafayette, Indiana, 2025

We've analysed 12 Property Manager companies in Lafayette, IN.
Let our Team + AI help you match with the best for your project.

How it Works: Tell Us About Your Project | Get Matched on Your Unique Criteria | Receive Quotes via Email from Up to 3 Companies

Refine Your Search

Use the filters below to narrow down your options and find the perfect match.

PMI Lafayette

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Frankfort, IN | Lafayette, IN | West Lafayette, IN | Dayton, IN + 1 Other

PMI Lafayette is a full-service real estate asset management company that provides professional Residential, Commercial, and Realty services across Lafayette, Indiana and surrounding communities. They utilize state-of-the-art technology to help property owners manage their investments and provide tenants with real-time access to maintenance requests and billing.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family
  • Commercial
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 34 reviews.
  • "PMI is an excellent property management company!" - Lori

Crandall Enterprises

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Frankfort, IN | Kokomo, IN | Lafayette, IN | West Lafayette, IN + 2 Others

Crandall Enterprises is a full-service property management company serving the Lafayette and West Lafayette, Indiana areas. They efficiently connect tenants and investment property owners, providing professional and personal services for a variety of property types including single and multi-family homes, townhomes, condos, and commercial spaces.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Student Housing
  • HOA
  • Multi-Family
  • Commercial
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 20 reviews.
  • "Anytime anything has needed fixed it's been fixed within 24 hrs" - Kristi
  • "Extremely respectful and easy to work with" - Arjun
  • "Thank you for giving people chances to overcome there obstacles and grow" - Jamie

The Russell Company

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Delphi, IN | Lafayette, IN | Monticello, IN | New Richmond, IN + 1 Other

The Russell Team is a real estate company that has been serving the Greater Lafayette Area in Indiana for nearly 50 years. They specialize in residential and commercial real estate, providing services such as real estate brokerage and property management to buyers, sellers, investors, and renters across the region.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Commercial
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 59 reviews.
  • "Cathy was very patient" - Teresa
  • "Rosie explained everything" - Brett
  • "Stacy went above and beyond" - Chelsea

Schwering Realty, LLC

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Kokomo, IN | Lafayette, IN | Logansport, IN | Peru, IN + 2 Others

Schwering Realty is a full-service real estate firm specializing in the marketing, listing, and selling of residential, commercial, and multi-family properties in Cass County and north-central Indiana. With over 20 years of experience and a team of well-trained professionals, they provide exceptional service to both buyers and sellers.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family
  • Commercial
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 37 reviews.
  • "They are very fair" - Bradley
  • "They are really nice" - Raylee
  • "Always take good care of me" - Gasyman

BK Management

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Anderson, IN | Connersville, IN | Crawfordsville, IN | Delphi, IN + 22 Others

BK Management is a property management company that specializes in managing and maintaining a large portfolio of high-quality single and multi-unit family homes, with a focus on student housing for Purdue University and Ball State University students across Indiana and Illinois.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Student Housing
  • Multi-Family

Sorola Properties

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Lafayette, IN | West Lafayette, IN

Sorola Properties is a full-service property management company specializing in residential, multi-family, and commercial real estate in Lafayette and West Lafayette, Indiana. They offer expertise in managing rental properties, as well as assisting clients with buying and selling homes in the local market.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family
  • Commercial
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 45 reviews.
  • "Sorola Properties people were great to work with" - Tom
  • "Gilbert and his staff are outstanding" - David
  • "he got the paperwork done, helped secure the documentation and loan needed" - George

SmartDigs LLC

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Lafayette, IN | West Lafayette, IN

SmartDigs is a property management company that specializes in managing around 200 apartment and house rentals in West Lafayette and Lafayette, Indiana, near Purdue University. They are known for their unique floor plans and pet-friendly units, catering to both residential and commercial tenants.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family
  • Commercial
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 32 reviews.
  • "Many of the apartments have also been newly built or renovated too!" - Rigert
  • "The maintenance staff addressed issues promptly and efficiently communicated what they did." - Avril
  • "The SmartDigs management staff is absolutely wonderful to work with." - Paige

Cagan Management Group, Inc.

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Jacksonville, FL | Kissimmee, FL | Orlando, FL | Chicago, IL + 3 Others

Cagan Management Group is a property management company that specializes in managing apartments, condominiums, and commercial properties across the Midwest and Southeast regions of the United States, with a focus on Illinois, Florida, and Indiana.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • COA
  • Multi-Family
  • Commercial
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 258 reviews.
  • "Immediate responsiveness" - Aaron
  • "Ms Jeanie is the absolute best" - Dacotah
  • "Chris always been straight forward" - luis

Main Street Management, LLC

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Indianapolis, IN | Lafayette, IN

Main Street Management, LLC is a full-service property management firm serving commercial properties and HOA communities in the Lafayette and Indianapolis areas of Indiana. With expertise in financial services, maintenance management, and resident relations, they provide tailored solutions to enhance property investments and ensure smooth operations for their clients.

Property Types:
  • HOA
  • Commercial
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 47 reviews.
  • "William, Joey, and Mary have always been available" - Lena
  • "Marissa goes above and beyond" - Mark
  • "They are timely, detailed, do great work" - Brian

Russell Property Management

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Crawfordsville, IN | Delphi, IN | Frankfort, IN | Lafayette, IN + 6 Others

Russell Property Management is a residential property management company serving the West Lafayette and greater Lafayette areas of Indiana. They specialize in providing well-maintained and move-in ready rental homes to tenants across the region. With a focus on clean, quality properties, Russell Property Management aims to deliver a hassle-free rental experience for their clients.

Property Types:
  • Residential
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 45 reviews.
  • "Jim and Nikki were always highly responsive" - Lily
  • "Mr. Boyle is approachable, attentive, and genuinely invested" - Alex
  • "Jim is super responsive and understands" - Golden

Father & Son Property Maintenance & Management

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Anderson, IN | Connersville, IN | Crawfordsville, IN | Kokomo, IN + 11 Others

Father & Son Property Maintenance is a residential contractor serving the Anderson, Indiana area. As a family-run business, they provide reliable property maintenance and repair services for homeowners with a focus on quality workmanship and customer satisfaction.

Property Types:
  • Residential
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 40 reviews.
  • "Highly recommend these guys" - Montgomery
  • "I would recommend this company" - Betty
  • "His crew was on time, polite" - Kreative

Accurate Property Management

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Lafayette, IN | West Lafayette, IN

Accurate Property Management is a trusted property management and building maintenance company serving the Lafayette and West Lafayette areas of Indiana. They provide comprehensive services for both residential and commercial properties, including property management, building management, and commercial renovations and repairs. With years of experience and a dedicated team, Accurate Property Management ensures properties remain attractive and well-maintained, delivering a hassle-free experience for property owners and an appealing living or working environment for tenants.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Commercial
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 26 reviews.
  • "They are the most attentive landlords" - Walker
  • "APM goes above and beyond" - Rylee
  • "Andrew is a phenomenal landlord" - Jessica