Verified Property Management Professionals in Orange Park, Florida, 2026

"Clients say this property management company has provided poor service, with issues like unresponsive staff, delayed repairs, and disputes over security deposits. However, some clients have praised the maintenance team for their helpful service."

"In general, clients of Real Property Management First Coast have had very positive experiences with the company's services. Reviewers highlight the excellent communication, responsiveness, and attention to detail provided by the property manager Jon Smith. Clients mention that Jon was able to quickly find tenants for their properties, handle repairs and maintenance efficiently, and make the overall rental process smooth and stress-free."

"Clients say Keshman Property Management, led by Joseph Keshi, provides excellent property management services. Reviewers praise Joseph's professionalism, responsiveness, and attention to detail in handling all aspects of property management, from tenant screening to maintenance and repairs. Clients appreciate Joseph's transparency, communication, and ability to quickly resolve any issues that arise, giving them peace of mind that their properties are in capable hands."

"In general, reviews indicate that Traditions Realty, LLC is a highly professional and client-focused real estate company that has helped many clients with their real estate needs. Clients frequently mention the excellent service and responsiveness of specific team members, such as Beth King, Franklin McDaniel, and Diana, who have gone above and beyond to assist them. The company is praised for its ability to find quality tenants, manage properties efficiently, and facilitate smooth transactions, whether for rentals or sales."

"Client reviews say River Oak Realty is a professional and reliable property management company that provides excellent service to its clients. Reviewers praise the company's responsiveness, communication, and the dedicated efforts of specific team members like Sue, Terra Brooks, and Rick Conrad in addressing tenant needs and managing properties efficiently. Overall, clients express satisfaction with the company's services and recommend them to others."

"Generally, clients of Quest Real Estate, LLC have been very satisfied with the company's professional and responsive property management services. Reviewers highlight the company's ability to quickly resolve issues, find reliable tenants, and provide cost-effective solutions, even for owners who do not live locally. The overall sentiment expressed is that Quest Real Estate, LLC is a trustworthy and reliable partner for real estate needs."

"Clients of PMI Davis Realty have generally had positive experiences with the company's property management services. Reviewers praise the professionalism and responsiveness of the team, particularly Kristen Morgan, who is noted for her excellent communication, timely handling of maintenance requests, and smooth transitions during the rental and sale process. The company is described as treating clients' properties as their own and providing great customer service."

"Overall reviews for Legacy Realty Group North Florida, Inc. are mixed, with some clients praising the company's services and personnel, particularly Zelda and Elliot, who were described as knowledgeable, responsive, and helpful in the home buying process. However, other reviews mention issues with the broker\/owner, such as lack of communication, unprofessional behavior, and difficulty reaching the company."

"Overall reviews for Hover Girl Properties are highly positive, with clients praising the company's professionalism, responsiveness, and attention to detail. Reviewers highlight the excellent service provided by specific team members like Maddy, Lauren, Josh, and Tina, who have made the rental and property management process smooth and stress-free, especially for military families and out-of-state clients. The company is commended for its ability to handle all aspects of property management, from finding reliable tenants to addressing maintenance issues efficiently."

"Overall, clients say PMI Jacksonville is a professional and experienced property management company that has helped investors and property owners manage their real estate assets effectively. Reviewers highlight the team's responsiveness, attention to detail, and ability to handle various property management tasks, from tenant relations to maintenance, allowing owners to maximize their investments."

"Clients say Signature Realty & Management, Inc. (Mandarin HQ) has some issues with responsiveness and professionalism, but the company has also received positive reviews for its property management services, particularly from clients who have worked with specific realtors like Michelle Richey Martin, Cindy Sanders, and Lynne."

"Overall, clients say the owner and staff at Island Realty Inc are amazing, knowledgeable, and extremely sweet. The company is praised for its friendly and professional service, though some reviewers have had negative experiences and recommend seeking good representation when dealing with the firm."

Overall, clients say Kellar Realty and Property Management provides excellent property management services, with a responsive and professional team that quickly addresses tenant needs and maintains properties well. Specific team members like Denise Greenwood and Eddie Kellar are praised for their personable and helpful approach in managing properties and assisting both tenants and property owners.