In Florida, Dated and Inherited Homes Are Selling Faster Than Polished Listings

Written by:

Alejandra Rodriguez

Date:

01 May 2026

Share

Share via Facebook

Share via Linkedin

Share via X

Copy to clipboard

Everyone assumes the most desirable, move-in-ready homes in Florida are flying off the market. And sometimes they are. But a quieter pattern is emerging — one where dated, overlooked, and inherited properties are finding buyers faster than many polished listings, and where sellers who expected top dollar are watching their homes sit for months.

Rising insurance premiums, higher property taxes following the 2021–2023 price surge, and persistent pressure on mortgage rates have changed the math for both buyers and sellers. In that environment, realistic pricing has become more important than curb appeal — and the sellers willing to meet the market are the ones getting deals done.

Ron Myers, president of Ron Buys Florida Homes, has been buying and selling Florida residential properties for over two decades. He works closest to the part of the market most people don’t see: the homes that need work, the estates that were left behind, and the sellers who need to get out quickly.

The Listings That Are Sitting Longest

Some of the hardest homes to sell in Florida right now are the ones priced at the top of their neighborhood — even when they’re in decent shape. Myers has watched sellers take an agent’s optimistic valuation, list at a high price, and then spend months slowly cutting the price. “I’m seeing a lot of agents quoting high amounts and then just chopping at the tree,” he says, “dropping it three, five, ten, fifteen percent until the house finally sells.”

The homes that tend to linger share a few traits: they’re priced based on comparisons to nearby fully renovated homes, they need cosmetic updates, or they’re competing in neighborhoods where buyers now have real options. In a market where carrying costs are climbing and buyers are more selective, overpriced listings are getting punished quickly.

What’s Actually Moving

Properties priced honestly — even those that need work — are finding traction. Myers says more sellers are coming to him after their traditional listing stalled. The home sat, the contract lapsed, and now they want a different path. These are often homes that were priced too high initially, but once expectations reset, they move.

Inherited properties are another segment that’s quietly active. Heirs who receive a home they don’t want, can’t maintain, or can’t afford to repair are motivated to sell and are flexible on price. These homes often need updating, but they’re priced to reflect that — making them attractive to buyers willing to do some work or investors looking for margin.

Myers notes that many of these properties have been neglected for years, and the sellers want to offload them in their current condition. “A lot of inherited properties have just kind of been forgotten about,” he says.

Why the Math Has Changed

The pressure on sellers comes from several converging forces. Insurance costs have surged across Florida, especially on the Gulf Coast. Property taxes climbed after years of rapid appreciation. And mortgage rates have stayed elevated, making buyers more cautious and more willing to negotiate hard.

Sellers who bought at the peak — or who are carrying high ongoing costs — face real pressure to move. Buyers, for the first time in years, have the patience to wait for the right deal rather than rushing to bid.

What You Should Do Now

If you’re buying: Don’t overlook homes that need cosmetic work. Sellers of dated or inherited properties are often more flexible on price and terms than sellers of turnkey homes. Ask for closing cost credits, inspection repairs, or a price reduction — they’re more likely to say yes than they were two years ago.

If you’re selling a dated or inherited home: Price it based on what similar homes actually sold for in the last 90 days — not what they were listed for, and not what renovated homes nearby are asking. A realistic price upfront will save you months of carrying costs and repeated reductions.

If you’re selling a renovated or move-in-ready home, you still have an edge, but only if you price correctly. Buyers today are comparing your home to everything else available, and they’re taking their time. Staging, professional photos, and a sharp price point matter more now than they did when buyers were competing for limited inventory.

The Bottom Line

Florida’s real estate market is rewarding realistic pricing over presentation. The homes finding buyers aren’t always the prettiest — they’re the ones priced for the market as it actually is, not as sellers wish it were. Overpriced listings, meanwhile, are sitting on the market longer and costing their owners more each month in taxes, insurance, and carrying costs.

For sellers still holding out for peak-era numbers, the risk is real. Every month, the market adds expense without guaranteeing a better offer. As Myers puts it, “If they’re looking for a top dollar number they can’t move off of, they might just be better off waiting — but the market may not cooperate.”

About the Expert: Ron Myers is the president of Ron Buys Florida Homes and has spent over two decades buying and selling residential properties across the state. He specializes in the segment of the market most buyers and sellers rarely see — inherited homes, distressed properties, and listings that need a different path to closing.

This article is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or investment advice. The views and opinions expressed herein reflect those of the individuals quoted and do not represent an endorsement of any company, product, or service mentioned. Readers should conduct their own due diligence and consult qualified professionals before making any investment decisions.