Orlando's Starter Home Problem: Why First-Time Buyers Are Stuck – And Where the Deals Actually Are

Written by:

Alejandra Rodriguez

Date:

01 Apr 2026

Share

Share via Facebook

Share via Linkedin

Share via X

Copy to clipboard

You’ve saved for a down payment and are ready to buy your first home in Orlando—then you see the prices, and the dream suddenly feels out of reach. Orlando’s affordability crisis has left first-time buyers squeezed by high prices, limited inventory in the entry-level range, and a condo market that’s virtually stalled. Yet there are still ways to buy if you know where to look and what to avoid.

Where First-Time Buyers Get Stuck

Most first-time buyers in Orlando start their search around $500,000, according to Brenden Rendo, broker associate with The Homes in Orlando Team. For most, that number is unrealistic. Rendo advises buyers to treat their first home as an investment and set their sights lower.

To buy without overextending, Rendo says buyers should focus on homes in the $300,000 to $350,000 range. At this price, expect older homes that may need updates, less square footage, and possibly two bedrooms rather than three. “Everybody wants everything mint, but we can’t all afford the mint,” Rendo says.

Rising land and development costs are a major factor. Developers pay steep prices for buildable lots—sometimes $27 million for 47 acres in Clermont—resulting in $50,000 to $60,000 per house in infrastructure, permitting, and impact fees before construction even begins. These costs are passed directly to buyers, driving up entry-level prices.

Why Condos Aren’t the Answer

Condos, often seen as affordable starter homes, aren’t solving the problem in Orlando. The local condo market is nearly frozen, with only about 100 condos selling each week out of 4,000 to 4,500 listed. Average days on market have climbed to around 120.

The main issue is rising HOA fees. Where monthly dues once averaged $200, many now exceed $600, with some reaching $957. Rendo points out that a $600 monthly HOA fee adds up to the same monthly payment as an extra $60,000 on a mortgage. “You could buy a larger single-family home for the same payment,” he says.

Financing is another hurdle. Few Orlando condos are FHA-approved, so buyers relying on FHA loans face a slow “spot approval” process that can take three to four months—far longer than most sellers are willing to wait.

New Construction: Incentives With Limits

Builders are offering significant incentives to move new homes, especially interest rate buydowns. Some builders are lowering 30-year fixed rates to as little as 4.5% using credits—making a $450,000 home more affordable than at today’s typical 7% rates.

These deals, however, mostly benefit cash investors rather than first-time buyers who need financing. Cash buyers can negotiate directly for price cuts or upgrades, bypassing the builder’s advertised incentives.

Rendo recently helped an investor purchase a new construction home for $339,000. The identical house next door, bought a year earlier by a traditional buyer, sold for $401,000—a $62,000 difference for the same property.

Townhomes: An Unpopular Option

Builders have ramped up construction of townhomes, hoping to fill the affordability gap. The demand hasn’t materialized. Rendo notes that “townhomes” are among the least-searched real estate terms in Orlando. In one new subdivision, only three out of 20 completed townhomes have sold; the rest sit vacant.

Buyers are avoiding townhomes due to shared walls, restrictive HOA rules, and limited outdoor space—especially since smaller, older single-family homes are still available for similar prices.

Where the Real Opportunities Are

For first-time buyers, Rendo recommends three strategies:

1. Target homes with long days on market. Properties listed for 120 days or more often have motivated sellers. Offering $20,000 below asking—backed by cash or a strong pre-approval—can lead to successful negotiations.
2. Look beyond Orlando’s city limits. In Ocala, about 90 minutes north, builders like Lennar are listing new homes under $300,000, some as low as $289,000 for 1,400 square feet. Ocala’s market has cooled, creating opportunities for buyers priced out of Orlando.
3. View starter homes as stepping stones. Rendo is building 1,100-square-foot homes on quarter-acre lots in Inverness, starting at $247,000. He encourages buyers to use these as entry points—build equity for a few years, then either upgrade or keep the home as a rental to help fund the next purchase.

Affordability Isn’t Returning Soon

Home values in Orlando have dipped 4% to 5% from their peak, but that’s not enough to restore true affordability. The flow of out-of-state buyers has slowed sharply; Florida added about 23,000 new residents in 2025, down from 350,000 to 450,000 annually during the pandemic boom.

Large institutional investors, including BlackRock, are now selling properties rather than expanding their portfolios. While this creates more opportunities for individual buyers, it also signals that even major players see risks in the current market.

What This Means for Buyers

First-time buyers in Orlando need to adjust their expectations. The $500,000 dream home isn’t realistic for most. But a $300,000 starter home that fits your budget and allows you to build equity is still attainable.

“Your level of expectation has to adjust,” Rendo says. “Nothing’s getting less expensive. So getting people to pull the trigger is really hard.” For buyers willing to start smaller and think long-term, opportunities remain—even in a challenging market.

About the Expert: Brenden Rendo is a broker associate with The Homes in Orlando Team, specializing in affordable starter homes and investment properties across Central Florida.

This article is based on information provided by the expert source cited above. It is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or real estate advice. Readers should conduct their own research and consult qualified professionals before making any real estate or financial decisions.