First-Time Buyers Face New Tradeoffs as Entry-Level Homes Disappear

Written by:

Steve Marcinuk

Date:

22 Dec 2025

Share

Share via Facebook

Share via Linkedin

Share via X

Copy to clipboard

Traditional sub-$300,000 resale homes in established neighborhoods have become scarce, forcing first-time buyers to reconsider what homeownership looks like in 2025. According to Donna Kreps, President of Residential Real Estate Services at F.C. Tucker Company, the main challenge is not high prices or elevated mortgage rates, but the disappearance of entry-level inventory in the locations buyers most want.

Kreps, who has worked in real estate for 36 years and purchased her first home at 18, says the days when first-time buyers could expect to find an affordable fixer-upper in a desirable, established community are over. “First-time buyers may not get their number one location with what the current market has looked like, but there are still wonderful opportunities,” Kreps says.

Inventory Shortage in Established Neighborhoods

For decades, first-time buyers relied on older homes in established neighborhoods – properties with “good bones but needing updates” – as their entry point. Kreps says these homes are now being purchased by other buyer groups, such as investors and move-up buyers, leaving little available for first-time buyers. As a result, traditional entry-level options in central and established locations have “largely disappeared.”

New Construction Fills the Gap

With resale inventory tight, Kreps points to new construction as a practical solution for first-time buyers. “Builders are offering great opportunities. New construction is a way for a person to get into their first home, because many builders are offering incentives,” she says. These incentives may include closing cost assistance, upgrades, or other financial benefits that can make a new home more accessible than many assume.

Kreps also emphasizes that buyers do not need to navigate new construction transactions alone. “Builders welcome buyers having their own representation, and so having your own agent help you with the builder can also help you reach your goals,” she notes. Having an agent can ensure buyers understand the process, negotiate effectively, and avoid common pitfalls.

However, the shift toward new construction means first-time buyers must often consider developing areas outside the urban core. “They may have to go outside of the city to get the house they want,” Kreps says, highlighting a trend where buyers are prioritizing new homes in growing suburbs over older homes in established neighborhoods.

Financing Options Remain Available

Contrary to headlines suggesting that financing barriers are the primary obstacle, Kreps says most first-time buyers have access to a range of loan options. “There’s an FHA product that they can buy with as little as 3.5% down,” she explains. USDA loans may offer 100% financing, depending on location, and some local banks have special programs for first-time buyers who meet qualifying criteria. F.C. Tucker’s affiliated mortgage company also provides incentives tailored for this segment.

Kreps stresses that while financing is available, the real constraints are affordability and location. “The real issue is affordability, because housing prices have gone up so much,” she says. Many buyers must weigh the tradeoff between their preferred location and what they can realistically afford.

Growth Corridors Redefine First-Time Buyer Markets

As the market changes, first-time buyer activity is concentrating in new growth corridors around Indianapolis. Kreps points to areas such as Whitestown, Lebanon, Morgan County, Johnson County, and eastern Hancock County, where new construction and business investment are driving both job creation and housing development. “What’s happening in Whitestown and Lebanon and all of that growth with the new business that’s coming in that direction” signals opportunity for buyers willing to look beyond traditional neighborhoods, Kreps says.

These areas were not historically considered first-time buyer markets, but now represent the places where affordable inventory and new homes are most available. Kreps says this geographic expansion benefits the broader region: “It allows businesses to come to the state of Indiana because they know their employees can afford housing here.” As employers invest in these corridors, they create a positive feedback loop of job growth and housing demand.

Importance of Professional Guidance

Kreps believes that navigating today’s first-time buyer market requires more professional guidance than in the past. “I would encourage first-time home buyers to seek the counsel of an educated, well-informed agent with experience to help them navigate the process,” she says. The decisions facing buyers now involve complex tradeoffs between location, new versus resale, community development, school districts, and long-term value.

Choosing between stretching for an older home in an established area or opting for new construction further out can affect not only the initial purchase but also future appreciation and lifestyle. “It’s just getting with that educated, experienced agent who knows how to introduce you to the right product,” Kreps emphasizes, noting that generic advice or national headlines rarely address the realities of the local market.

Tucker’s Approach: Education and Realistic Expectations

F.C. Tucker’s strategy for first-time buyers focuses on education and managing expectations rather than discouraging homeownership aspirations. Kreps describes first-time buyers as “a segment of our buying population that’s very important to me.” The firm connects buyers with agents who understand both available financing and the full range of geographic options. “It depends where the buyer is going to purchase,” Kreps says, underlining that solutions differ by area and price point.

The main message, according to Kreps, is that homeownership remains achievable in the Indianapolis area for first-time buyers willing to consider new locations and property types. “There are still wonderful opportunities, and there are financing opportunities to help them reach their goals,” she says.

Looking to 2026, Kreps expects conditions to remain favorable for first-time buyers. “I think it’s a great time to buy,” she says, predicting that interest rates will stay near current levels or fall slightly, which would still be historically low. Whether buyers embrace these new tradeoffs – prioritizing affordability and new construction in emerging areas over established locations – will determine how accessible homeownership remains for this segment in the coming years.