Verified Agent, Team &amp; Broker Professionals in Marathon, Florida, 2026

Florida Keys Real Estate Group, led by Principal Broker Kristen Brenner alongside partners Tierce Scheel and Margie Casey, specializes in luxury waterfront properties throughout the Florida Keys. As Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialists and the #1 selling team on Duck Key with over $600 million in closed sales, the team provides exceptional expertise in luxury residences, waterfront estates, and vacation properties from Key Largo to Key West.

Property Types:

Residential

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Keys Real Estate
This business has not yet been verified. Verified status is granted after a short phone interview confirming credentials and professional background.

Key West, FL | Marathon, FL | Key Largo, FL | Big Pine Key, FL + 1 Other

Short Term Rental Manager

Property Management

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Knight and Gardner Realty is a leading real estate company in the Florida Keys, specializing in residential, commercial, and vacation properties. With over 60 years of experience and a team of local experts, they provide comprehensive services including sales, property management, and vacation rentals across Key West, the Lower, Middle, and Upper Keys.

Property Types:

Residential
Multifamily
Retail
Industrial
Hospitality
Land
Manufactured Housing

In general, clients praise the professionalism, expertise, and dedication of the Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Keys Real Estate team. Reviewers highlight the agents' deep knowledge of the local real estate market, their ability to guide clients through the buying and selling process, and their commitment to ensuring a smooth and successful transaction. Specific team members, such as Matt Zelko, Lynn Lucas, Jody, and Stacey Pillari, are mentioned for their exceptional service and negotiation skills.

Katie Carrillo - Florida Keys Realtor
This business has not yet been verified. Verified status is granted after a short phone interview confirming credentials and professional background.

Key West, FL | Marathon, FL

Short Term Rental Manager

Katie Carrillo is a seasoned real estate agent with over 30 years of experience in the Florida Keys market. She specializes in residential and commercial real estate, helping buyers and sellers navigate the unique Florida Keys real estate landscape.

Property Types:

Residential
Hospitality

In general, clients praise Katie Carrillo's exceptional real estate services, highlighting her professionalism, responsiveness, and deep knowledge of the Florida Keys market. Reviewers emphasize her ability to understand their needs, provide personalized guidance, and deliver a seamless experience from start to finish, whether buying, selling, or managing rental properties.

Sandra Tuttle, Florida Keys Realtor | Island Welcome Real Estate
This business has not yet been verified. Verified status is granted after a short phone interview confirming credentials and professional background.

Key West, FL | Marathon, FL | Key Largo, FL | Big Pine Key, FL + 7 Others

Island Welcome Real Estate is a specialized real estate agency serving the Florida Keys region, with a focus on residential properties. They have extensive local expertise and a passion for helping clients find their dream homes in this tropical paradise.

Property Types:

Residential

In general, reviews of Sandra Tuttle and Island Welcome Real Estate are overwhelmingly positive. Clients praise Sandra's expertise, communication skills, and dedication to ensuring a smooth and successful real estate transaction. Reviewers highlight Sandra's deep knowledge of the Florida Keys market, her proactive approach, and her ability to go above and beyond to address any issues that arise. Many clients express their appreciation for Sandra's professionalism, patience, and commitment to helping them find their dream home or sell their property.

The Silvestri Team | Key Largo Real Estate Agents
This business has not yet been verified. Verified status is granted after a short phone interview confirming credentials and professional background.

Key West, FL | Marathon, FL | Tavernier, FL | Key Largo, FL + 3 Others

The Silvestri Team is a dynamic real estate team specializing in investment properties, commercial ventures, and residential homes in the captivating Florida Keys. With deep local expertise and a commitment to professionalism, they help clients navigate the intricacies of the market to uncover high-potential opportunities and safeguard their investments.

Property Types:

Residential
Multifamily

Overall, clients say the Silvestri Team is a knowledgeable, dedicated, and professional group of real estate agents who go above and beyond to help their clients find their dream homes. They are praised for their extensive market knowledge, willingness to work around clients' schedules, and genuine care for their clients' best interests.

Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate Destinations
This business has not yet been verified. Verified status is granted after a short phone interview confirming credentials and professional background.

Key West, FL | Marathon, FL | Key Largo, FL | Big Pine Key, FL + 1 Other

Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate Destinations is a full-service real estate company specializing in the Florida Keys market, offering expertise in residential, commercial, and specialty properties from Key Largo to Key West. Their team of experienced REALTORS® provides exclusive buyer and seller representation, as well as property management and vacation rental services, to help clients achieve their real estate goals.

Property Types:

Residential
Multifamily
Land

Clients say the real estate agents at Better Homes & Gardens Real Estate Destinations in the Florida Keys are highly knowledgeable, dedicated, and go above and beyond to ensure their clients' needs are met. The company is praised for its exceptional industry expertise, genuine commitment to clients, and collaborative environment that makes every interaction a pleasure. Reviewers highlight the team's dedication, expertise, and client-focused approach as standout qualities that make them a trusted partner in the real estate journey.

Dream Life Realty
This business has not yet been verified. Verified status is granted after a short phone interview confirming credentials and professional background.

Miami, FL | Bonita Springs, FL | Cape Coral, FL | Fort Lauderdale, FL + 12 Others

Dream Life Realty is a full-service real estate company that specializes in residential, multi-family, and commercial properties across Florida, with a focus on key markets like Miami, Fort Lauderdale, Coral Gables, and Aventura. They offer a range of services, including real estate brokerage, to help clients buy, sell, and invest in properties throughout the Sunshine State.

Property Types:

Residential

Generally, reviews for Dream Life Realty are very positive, with clients highlighting the company's excellent service, knowledgeable and professional agents, and the strong support and training provided to its sales associates. Reviewers mention the brokerage's 100% commission structure, in-house services like lending and title, and the overall collaborative and successful environment at the firm.

Brett and Margo Newman, Realtors, Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate Co.
This business has not yet been verified. Verified status is granted after a short phone interview confirming credentials and professional background.

Marathon, FL | Tavernier, FL | Key Largo, FL | Islamorada, FL + 4 Others

The Newman Team is a top-selling Florida Keys real estate team that specializes in luxury waterfront, oceanfront, and boating-friendly properties in the Upper Florida Keys region, including Islamorada, Key Largo, and surrounding areas. With over 25 years of experience and over $500 million in closed sales, they are among the top 1% of real estate agents nationwide.

Property Types:

Residential
Land

Action Keys Realty Inc
This business has not yet been verified. Verified status is granted after a short phone interview confirming credentials and professional background.

Key West, FL | Marathon, FL | Big Pine Key, FL | Summerland Key, FL + 2 Others

Short Term Rental Manager

Property Management

Action Keys Realty is a full-service real estate brokerage and property management firm specializing in the Florida Keys, offering personalized services for residential and commercial properties, including luxury homes, waterfront properties, vacation rentals, and long-term rentals.

Property Types:

Residential
Hospitality
Land

Thomas Weger LLC, a REALTOR® for Premiere Plus Realty Co.
This business has not yet been verified. Verified status is granted after a short phone interview confirming credentials and professional background.

Fort Myers, FL | Marathon, FL | Marco Island, FL | Naples, FL

Thomas Weger LLC is a REALTOR® with Premiere Plus Realty Co., specializing in luxury residential properties in the Naples, Marco Island, and greater Southwest Florida areas. With an exclusive portfolio of high-end listings, Thomas provides expert guidance and personalized service to discerning buyers and sellers in this premier real estate market.

Property Types:

Residential

The Irwins - Realtors Key West & The Florida Keys
This business has not yet been verified. Verified status is granted after a short phone interview confirming credentials and professional background.

Key West, FL | Marathon, FL | Tavernier, FL | Key Largo, FL + 11 Others

The Irwins - Realtors Key West & The Florida Keys is a husband and wife real estate team dedicated to providing sincere customer service in the Florida Keys area. Based in Key West and working with Preferred Properties Real Estate Brokerage, Elise and Mike Irwin guide buyers and sellers through residential transactions with a personalized approach. Their local expertise spans Key West and surrounding island communities like Marathon, Islamorada, and Key Largo, helping clients achieve their real estate goals in this unique island chain.

Property Types:

Residential

RE/MAX Keys Connection
This business has not yet been verified. Verified status is granted after a short phone interview confirming credentials and professional background.

Key West, FL | Marathon, FL | Key Largo, FL | Islamorada, FL

RE/MAX Keys Connection is a commercial and multi-family real estate brokerage serving the Florida Keys region, including Key West, Key Largo, Islamorada, Marathon, and the Big Pine & Lower Keys areas. Their team of experienced agents specializes in commercial properties and investment opportunities across the Keys.

Property Types:

Multifamily
Commercial

"In general, clients and real estate professionals have expressed very positive sentiments about RE\/MAX Keys Connection and its broker Curtis Skomp. Reviewers highlight Skomp's integrity, professionalism, responsiveness, and deep knowledge of the local real estate market in the Florida Keys. They mention how Skomp has helped clients find suitable commercial spaces, sell businesses, and navigate the local government processes effectively."

Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate Co.
This business has not yet been verified. Verified status is granted after a short phone interview confirming credentials and professional background.

Key West, FL | Marathon, FL | Tavernier, FL | Key Largo, FL + 11 Others

Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate Co. is a leading real estate brokerage serving the Florida Keys, specializing in residential properties throughout Key Largo, Islamorada, Marathon, and the surrounding island communities. With an extensive network of local agents and the powerful KeysListings.com platform, they provide unparalleled expertise in helping buyers and sellers navigate the unique Keys real estate market. Their commitment to personalized service and deep local knowledge ensures a seamless transaction experience.

Property Types:

Residential

"Overall, clients praise the professionalism, expertise, and exceptional service provided by the Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate Co. team, particularly realtors like Jim Signor, Jessica Gallagher, and Kerry Millhiser. Reviewers highlight the team's deep knowledge of the local market, responsiveness, and ability to guide clients smoothly through the real estate process, whether buying, selling, or investing."

Expert Insights & Market Analysis

In-depth research and expert perspectives from KeyCrew's research team and network of industry leaders, helping you make smarter real estate decisions.

Perspectives, Industry News, Residential Real Estate

Steve Marcinuk

Rising Shadow Inventory Signals Market Reset Ahead for Florida Keys

The Florida Keys residential market is experiencing a phenomenon that could alter the competitive landscape in early 2025, according to Margie Casey, Associate Broker at Florida Keys Real Es...

Residential Real Estate, KeyCrew Studio, Real Estate Investment, Real Estate Services

Heather Hook

Where Paradise Meets Provenance: Sombrero Beach and the Art of Keys Living

There are beaches, and then there is Sombrero Beach. Nestled at the southern tip of Marathon at Mile Marker 50 on the Atlantic side, Sombrero Beach stands in a class of its own among Florida...

Residential Real Estate, Real Estate Services, KeyCrew Studio

Heather Hook

7 Mile Bridge: Living Near the Eighth Wonder of the World

[Photo Credit – The Brenner Scheel & Casey Team] There are places in the world where the landscape itself feels like a privilege. The stretch of the Florida Keys surrounding the Se...

Residential Real Estate, Market Analysis & Policy, KeyCrew Studio, Real Estate Investment

Heather Hook

Step Off the Jet, Be Home in 15 Minutes: Inside the Florida Keys Most Coveted New Address

There is a particular kind of traveler for whom the friction of arrival matters as much as the destination itself. For that person – the one who measures journeys in efficiency and val...

Residential Real Estate, Commercial Real Estate, Industry Profiles, Featured Articles

Steve Marcinuk

Lisa Simonsen's Unconventional Path to Luxury Real Estate Success

“We are not sitting around waiting for anything to happen. We’re actively being creative and proactive, and we’re starting to see excellent results,” says Lisa Simons...