Best Property Manager Companies in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, 2025

MKE Leasing is a full-service real estate company that specializes in property management, leasing, and investment property services in the Milwaukee and Waukesha counties of Wisconsin. They offer a range of services including tenant placement, maintenance, rent collection, and financial reporting for residential and commercial properties.

Gonnering Realty Inc., led by Rose Bogosian, is a residential real estate brokerage serving the greater Kenosha and Racine areas of Wisconsin. As an experienced REALTOR® and broker/owner with over 30 years of expertise, Rose guides clients through buying, selling, and property management with a focus on exceptional service, local knowledge, and lasting relationships built on trust and integrity.

Pennybag Property Management is a full-service real estate company based in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. They offer a wide range of services including property management, renovations, handyman services, and home buying/selling. With a focus on residential and commercial properties, as well as affordable housing options, Pennybag provides comprehensive solutions tailored to clients' specific needs throughout the Milwaukee area.

PMI Property Pros is a full-service residential property management company serving the Milwaukee, Wisconsin area. As a locally owned franchise, they provide comprehensive services to help property owners maximize their real estate investments. With a focus on effective communication, accurate accounting, and attentive management, PMI Property Pros handles everything from marketing vacant properties to tenant screening, rent collection, maintenance coordination, and more. Their proven approach and technology platform give owners peace of mind that their rental homes are being professionally cared for.

Milwaukee Property Management LLC is a multi-family property management company serving the greater Milwaukee area in Wisconsin. They specialize in taking the stress out of managing investment properties through comprehensive services like marketing vacant units, thorough tenant screening, rent collection, maintenance coordination, and streamlined lease renewals. With a focus on multi-family residential properties, Milwaukee Property Management provides owners with convenient online portals and attentive local expertise.

Forest Green Realty & Management is a full-service real estate and property management company based in Greenfield, Wisconsin. They specialize in residential real estate sales, multi-family property management, and community association management services throughout the greater Milwaukee area. With a commitment to dedication, trust, and 24/7 quality customer service, Forest Green provides superior management solutions tailored to the needs of homeowners associations and residential investment properties.

Northland Management LLC is a family-owned property management company with over 50 years of experience in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. They specialize in providing well-maintained and competitively priced apartment homes, catering to both students and families. With multiple communities under their care, Northland offers a variety of floor plans and amenities, including private balconies, controlled access, indoor parking, and in-unit appliances. Their properties are conveniently located near trendy restaurants, shops, the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee campus, and recreational areas like the Oak Leaf Trail and lakefront.

Enigma Properties is a property management company specializing in quality multi-family residential rentals across the Milwaukee area. With a focus on exceptional service, they provide tenants with a tech-enhanced experience through secure online access for rent payments, maintenance requests, and more. Enigma's diverse portfolio offers a wide variety of comfortable housing options, ensuring residents can find their ideal home in Milwaukee's vibrant neighborhoods.

SNSHN Management & Realty is a full-service property management and real estate company based in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. They specialize in locating, purchasing, and maximizing returns for clients and partners through strategic investments and top-notch management services. With a client-focused approach, SNSHN provides reliable and honest property management tailored to each client's unique needs.

Schulhof Properties is a property management company specializing in student housing and multi-family residential properties near Marquette University in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. With over 30 years of experience serving the area, they offer a variety of well-maintained studio, 1-bedroom, 2-bedroom, and 3+ bedroom apartments with convenient amenities like on-site management, secure buildings, and laundry facilities. Schulhof Properties prides itself on providing safe, modern, and affordable housing options for Marquette students and the local community.

Bonnie Management is a commercial property management company that has been operating in the Midwest region since 1974. They provide hands-on, comprehensive management services to maximize the value of commercial real estate assets for their clients.

Minkin Management Inc. is a professional property management company that specializes in managing multi-family and hospitality properties. They offer comprehensive asset management and operational improvement services to ensure the properties, guests, tenants, and staff are well taken care of and running at optimal efficiency and profitability.

Appleton Rental Homes is a property management company that specializes in providing affordable, well-maintained rental homes and properties in the Milwaukee, Wisconsin area. They offer a range of services to tenants, including online rent payment, maintenance request management, and access to energy assistance programs.