Let Us Help: 1 (855) CREW-123

Best Property Manager Companies in Columbus, Ohio, 2025

We've analysed 95 Property Manager companies in Columbus, OH.
Let our Team + AI help you match with the best for your project.

How it Works: Tell Us About Your Project | Get Matched on Your Unique Criteria | Receive Quotes via Email from Up to 3 Companies

Refine Your Search

Use the filters below to narrow down your options and find the perfect match.

Peak Property Group Columbus

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Cincinnati, OH | Columbus, OH

Peak Property Group is a property management company that specializes in providing rental homes, apartments, and townhomes in the Columbus and Cincinnati, Ohio markets, including near The Ohio State University and University of Cincinnati. They offer a wide selection of pet-friendly housing options with modern amenities and on-demand maintenance support.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Student Housing
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 962 reviews.
  • "The maintenance team has been amazing" - Andrea
  • "Pat was so friendly, kind and helpful" - Gentrie
  • "Travis is wonderful- helped figure out our water issues very fast" - Victoria

Myers Real Estate

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Columbus, OH | Upper Arlington, OH | Grandview Heights, OH

Myers Real Estate is a full-service real estate firm in Columbus, Ohio that specializes in residential and commercial property sales, leasing, and management, as well as condominium and homeowners association (HOA) management. With nearly 100 years of experience, they serve buyers, sellers, tenants, and property owners across the Columbus metro area.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • HOA
  • COA
  • Multi-Family
  • Commercial
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 137 reviews.
  • "They've been super helpful" - Lizzy
  • "Excellent Service as a Owner" - denise
  • "One of THE best people" - Jake

ME Real Estate Columbus, Inc.

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Columbus, OH

ME Commercial is a full-service commercial real estate company that specializes in retail, office, and industrial properties. They have expertise in property management, brokerage, and development, helping businesses find the perfect commercial spaces to grow and thrive within their local communities.

Property Types:
  • Commercial
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 69 reviews.
  • "The maintenance is incredible" - Lauren
  • "The units are nicer than all others in the area" - Nick

Real Property Management Midwest

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Louisville, KY | Dayton, OH | Cincinnati, OH | Columbus, OH

RPM Midwest is a full-service property management company that specializes in managing residential, multi-family, and commercial properties in Ohio and Kentucky. They offer comprehensive services including tenant placement, 24/7 maintenance, and eviction protection, helping property owners maximize their investments.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family
  • Commercial
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 50 reviews.
  • "The process to sign up was very easy and straightforward!" - Ead
  • "They streamlined this process for me easily" - Alex
  • "Partnering with RPM was the greatest decision I ever made" - K.

FYVE Property Management - Arizona

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Miami, FL | Scottsdale, AZ | Daytona Beach, FL | Fort Lauderdale, FL + 13 Others

FYVE is a full-service property and community management company that provides trusted solutions for real estate investors and property owners across the Southeast and Mid-Atlantic regions. With expertise in residential, multi-family, and commercial properties, as well as HOA management, FYVE leverages leading technology and local market knowledge to maximize returns and streamline operations for its clients.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • HOA
  • Multi-Family
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 4 reviews.
  • "They have given me fines and fees" - Shaine

Northsteppe Realty

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Columbus, OH | Worthington, OH

NorthSteppe Realty is a property management company that specializes in providing quality urban living options for students and residents in the University District and Columbus, Ohio area. With locations across The Ohio State University campus and surrounding neighborhoods, they offer a wide range of rental properties to meet the diverse housing needs of their tenants.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Student Housing

Fourth Street Residential

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Carmel, IN | Newport, KY | Columbus, OH | Grove City, OH

Fourth Street Residential is a licensed real estate company that specializes in providing superior property management services. Founded by industry experts, the company is committed to delivering clean, comfortable living experiences and worry-free management benefits to both residents and owners in the communities it serves. With a focus on maintaining high-quality community experiences, Fourth Street Residential manages a portfolio of residential and multi-family properties across Ohio, Indiana, and Kentucky.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family

Monroe Group

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Kansas City, KS | Raleigh, NC | Fairbanks, AK | Inglewood, CA + 49 Others

Monroe Group is a leading affordable housing management company that operates over 90 properties with 9,000 units across 26 states. They specialize in providing high-quality property management services for affordable housing communities, serving low-income families, seniors, and individuals with disabilities.

Property Types:
  • Affordable Housing
  • Senior Housing
  • Multi-Family
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 35 reviews.
  • "This is one of the most well kept apartment complexes" - Laura
  • "Monroe group you have the best office staff" - Debbie
  • "Management at Weatherstone Apartments does their best" - Vicki

Monument Real Estate Services, Llc.

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Cleveland, OH | Columbus, OH

Monument Real Estate Services LLC is a full-service real estate brokerage and property management company specializing in urban investment properties in Cleveland, Ohio and other metropolitan areas. They offer comprehensive services including leasing, maintenance, and rent collection to help investors successfully manage their rental properties.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family
  • Commercial
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 107 reviews.
  • "Monument has been great to work with" - Mel
  • "They have a thorough understanding of the market" - Tamara
  • "We have been consistently impressed with their level of service" - okons

Capital Property Solutions CPS Columbus

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Columbus, OH | Worthington, OH

Capital Property Solutions is a leading property management company in the Columbus, Ohio area, providing comprehensive services for residential properties, condominiums, and homeowners associations (HOAs). With over 32 years of experience, they offer customized solutions to maximize returns on real estate investments and ensure well-maintained, safe communities.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • HOA
  • COA
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 470 reviews.
  • "If I need anything he is always there to serve" - Dan
  • "The Team at Capital Property Solutions CPS Columbus is really great!" - Deb
  • "they were VERY fast" - Mohammad

HomeRiver Group

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Kansas City, KS | Miami, FL | Oklahoma City, OK | Raleigh, NC + 38 Others

HomeRiver Group is a premier national property management company that provides a full range of services, including acquisition, renovation, leasing, management, maintenance, and brokerage, for residential and commercial properties across the United States.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family
  • Commercial
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 121 reviews.
  • "The Province Park Community is immaculate" - Steve
  • "They always make sure things are fixed as soon as possible" - ROSE
  • "Anthony Anderson has helped me multiple times with issues at my property" - Tyler

Serenity Stays Management

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Columbus, OH

Serenity Stays is a rental management company that provides short-term, mid-term, and long-term rental accommodations for individuals and groups visiting Columbus, Ohio for business or leisure. They offer fully furnished condos and houses with luxury amenities, catering to both busy executives and large families.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 2 reviews.
  • "They assisted me with multiple aspects of my rental business" - Angie
  • "Shan always provide a great experience" - Adrian

I Heart Real Estate PM

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Columbus, OH | Delaware, OH | Dublin, OH | Grove City, OH + 11 Others

I Heart Real Estate PM is a full-service residential property management company based in Dublin, Ohio. They specialize in managing rental properties for owners in the greater Columbus area, providing comprehensive services like tenant screening, maintenance coordination, and monthly financial reporting. With a commitment to affordable housing and a focus on clear communication, I Heart Real Estate PM aims to provide peace of mind for property investors through their attentive management approach.

Property Types:
  • Residential
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 97 reviews.
  • "The maintenance team is always very helpful and timely" - Lee
  • "The maintenance team always responds quickly!" - Megan
  • "Bishop provided great service" - Gina

Evernest

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Little Rock, AR | Tucson, AZ | Boulder, CO | Colorado Springs, CO + 23 Others

Evernest is a full-service property management company that specializes in managing single-family homes, condos, and small multifamily properties across 33 markets in the United States. They provide professional property management services, including tenant screening, maintenance, and accounting, to help owners maximize the returns on their rental investments.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family
  • Commercial

Oz Realty Toledo

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Dayton, OH | Cincinnati, OH | Cleveland, OH | Columbus, OH + 1 Other

Oz Realty is a full-service property management company serving the Toledo, Ohio area. They specialize in managing residential and multi-family properties, providing services such as tenant placement, maintenance, and financial management to real estate investors, both local and out-of-state.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 239 reviews.
  • "Martha was extremely helpful and a professional" - Granny
  • "The whole teams has been amazing from the start" - Karin
  • "Lonna was so helpful and took her time" - Roy