Let Us Help: 1 (855) CREW-123

Best Property Manager Companies in Indianapolis, Indiana, 2025

We've analysed 92 Property Manager companies in Indianapolis, IN.
Let our Team + AI help you match with the best for your project.

How it Works: Tell Us About Your Project | Get Matched on Your Unique Criteria | Receive Quotes via Email from Up to 3 Companies

Refine Your Search

Use the filters below to narrow down your options and find the perfect match.

AJD Real Estate

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Indianapolis, IN

AJD Real Estate Services is a full-service real estate firm that provides expertise in brokerage, property management, and contractor services for residential, multi-family, and commercial properties in the Indianapolis area.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family
  • Commercial
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 17 reviews.
  • "Matt has been extremely helpful" - Jasmine
  • "Matt is very great to work with" - Bryson
  • "Matt provided exceptional service" - Jorge

T&H Realty Services, Inc.

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Indianapolis, IN

TandH Realty Services is a full-service property management company based in Indianapolis, Indiana. They specialize in managing residential and multi-family rental properties, providing services such as tenant placement, maintenance, and financial management for investors and landlords in the Indianapolis area.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 1098 reviews.
  • "Carly Hunt made the process very quick and easy" - Connor
  • "Glenna has been consistently thorough, responsive, and professional" - Alex
  • "Anytime a maintenance issues arise they are prompt, professional" - Amanda

Brandywine Homes USA

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Jacksonville, FL | Orlando, FL | Ruskin, FL | Atlanta, GA + 12 Others

Brandywine Homes USA - FL is a property management company that specializes in managing residential and multi-family properties across multiple states, including New York, Florida, Georgia, Texas, South Carolina, Missouri, North Carolina, Tennessee, and Indiana.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 903 reviews.
  • "Jeremy came to the house and rebuilt the cabinets" - John
  • "Marvin provided outstanding plumbing services" - Rodney
  • "Marvin went above and beyond" - Jevon

Golden Sky Management

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Anderson, IN | Indianapolis, IN | Muncie, IN | New Castle, IN

Golden Sky Management is a premier property management company in Indiana, offering full-service management for residential, multi-family, commercial, and HOA properties. They utilize cutting-edge technology to provide exceptional, hands-on management, consistently exceeding market averages for occupancy rates and tenant satisfaction.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • HOA
  • Multi-Family
  • Commercial
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 135 reviews.
  • "The office staff are always kind and caring" - Kendra
  • "They've done a really good job with communication" - Chris
  • "They let you know what is going on" - Donna

Indiana Property Management Group LLC

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Brownsburg, IN | Carmel, IN | Greenwood, IN | Indianapolis, IN + 5 Others

Indiana Property Management Group, LLC is a professional property management company that efficiently and effectively manages residential and multi-family properties in the Indianapolis metropolitan area, providing exceptional service to both property owners and tenants.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 66 reviews.

Mynd Property Management

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Raleigh, NC | Phoenix, AZ | Tucson, AZ | Oakland, CA + 24 Others

Mynd is a tech-enabled property management and real estate investing platform that helps investors find, buy, lease, manage, and sell residential investment properties across 25+ US markets. They provide full-service property management with their integrated tech and services model, allowing investors to build and manage their portfolio remotely.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family
  • Commercial
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 1177 reviews.
  • "I really appreciated their response to work orders" - hopehorizon1

PMI Midwest

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Anderson, IN | Brownsburg, IN | Carmel, IN | Greenfield, IN + 16 Others

PMI Midwest is a full-service real estate asset management company that provides professional Residential, Commercial, and Realty services across the Indianapolis metropolitan area. They utilize state-of-the-art technology to help property owners manage their investments and provide tenants with real-time access to maintenance requests and billing.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family
  • Commercial
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 588 reviews.

Lighthouse Property Management

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Los Angeles, CA | Pasadena, CA | Altamonte Springs, FL | Jacksonville, FL + 8 Others

Lighthouse Property Management is a leading real estate operator that specializes in managing high-quality residential housing communities across the United States, with a focus on multi-family properties in major metropolitan areas like Los Angeles, Dallas, and Jacksonville.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • HOA
  • COA
  • Multi-Family
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 26 reviews.
  • "The leadership always asks for everyone's thoughts" - Christian
  • "They invest in personal & professional development" - Robert
  • "Supportive and innovative environment that encourages growth" - Liz

A Step Ahead Management

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Anderson, IN | Carmel, IN | Franklin, IN | Greenwood, IN + 8 Others

A Step Ahead Management is a full-service property management company specializing in the leasing and management of single-family homes in the Indianapolis metropolitan area. They provide quality homes and services that exceed the expectations of both property owners and residents.

Property Types:
  • Residential
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 192 reviews.
  • "Lisa was continuously prompt and respectful" - Cagney
  • "Their team is professional, responsive, and quick" - Cody
  • "They never once increased my rent" - Taylor

RR Living

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Indianapolis, IN | Gallatin, TN | Dallas, TX | Rockport, TX + 1 Other

RR Living is a property management company that specializes in providing luxury apartment living experiences for residents across the Southern United States. They focus on well-designed, amenity-rich communities that cater to the working American, offering flexible living options and a people-first approach to property management.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 76 reviews.
  • "I absolutely LOVE the way they give attention to every detail" - Timothy
  • "They went above and beyond" - christine

Elmstone Group Property Management, LLC

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Indianapolis, IN | Norman, OK | Knoxville, TN | Arlington, TX + 7 Others

Elmstone Group is a leading real estate investment and management firm in Texas, specializing in the acquisition, rehabilitation, and repositioning of multifamily and single-family properties. With a focus on providing exceptional service and creating value for investors, the company operates a full spectrum of real estate services across the region.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family

WILMOTH Group - Indianapolis Property Management

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Anderson, IN | Brownsburg, IN | Carmel, IN | Crawfordsville, IN + 74 Others

WILMOTH Group is a leading property management company in Indianapolis, providing comprehensive real estate services for over 30 years. They specialize in managing residential, multi-family, and commercial properties across central Indiana, offering expertise in tenant screening, maintenance, financial reporting, and more to help investors and property owners succeed.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family
  • Commercial
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 757 reviews.
  • "Max demonstrated an exceptional level of professionalism and expertise" - Jennifer
  • "They are much more responsive, proactive, and communicative" - Noelle
  • "Tenant concerns and property fixes were taken care of promptly" - Jennifer

Zuluscape

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Indianapolis, IN | Fishers, IN

Zuluscape is a full-service real estate company that provides property management, real estate sales, home maintenance, and remodeling services across central Indiana, with a focus on the residential and multi-family sectors.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 213 reviews.
  • "5 stars for Bennett" - Skylar
  • "Bennett has been nothing short of amazing" - cecil
  • "The customer service I received from Bennett today was excellent" - Pam

PMI Indianapolis

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Anderson, IN | Carmel, IN | Greenfield, IN | Greenwood, IN + 8 Others

PMI Indianapolis is a full-service real estate asset management company that provides professional Residential, Commercial, Short-Term, and Realty services across the Indianapolis metropolitan area. They utilize state-of-the-art technology to help property owners manage their investments and provide tenants with real-time access to maintenance requests and billing.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family
  • Commercial
  • Mixed-Use
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 578 reviews.
  • "Maintenance is very great" - Austin
  • "Albert has been extremely helpful" - Tyran
  • "Mr. John Perez was very helpful" - Lenjeeman

CRM Properties, Inc

This business has not yet claimed its profile and information provided here has not been verified. Response times vary.

Locations Served: This company offers services in the following locations.
Carmel, IN | Indianapolis, IN | Kokomo, IN | Muncie, IN

CRM Properties is a full-service Indianapolis property management company that helps real estate investors build wealth, save time, and eliminate stress by handling all aspects of property management, including resident screening, inspections, and maintenance.

Property Types:
  • Residential
  • Multi-Family
  • Commercial
Client rating:

KeyCrew analyzes reviews across multiple platforms to present concise insights for real estate investors.

Based on 378 reviews.
  • "Brittany is professional, prompt, and communicates exceptionally well" - Kurt
  • "Megan had amazing communication skills, time management was efficient" - Jada
  • "Megan and Janelle showed great teamwork and communicated perfectly" - Olivia